TV Gal

The Devil Made Me Do It . . . A Review of 'Reaper'

By Amy Amatangelo

   |  

March 2, 2009 11:20 AM

Bretharrison_reaper_s2_240 Reaper finally returns for a second season Tuesday at 8 p.m. on the CW.

If you didn't watch the show last year, no worries. It's easy to pick up and jump right in. Quick recap: on his 21st birthday Sam (Bret Harrison) discovered that his parents had sold his soul to the devil. That means that Sam is forced to become the Devil's (Ray Wise) bounty hunter with the help of his two friends Sock (Tyler Labine) and Ben (Rick Gonzalez). Last year, the show really heated up once Ken Marino and Michael Ian Black were introduced as demons leading a rebellion against the Devil and in the final moments of the season Sam learned that he was actually the Devil's son. Really that's all you need to know.

Season two kicks off with Sam, Sock and Ben returning from a mini-vacation to find out they've lost their jobs at the Work Bench and they've been kicked out of their apartment. And, of course, Sam must still do the Devil's bidding while trying to make amends with Andi (Missy Peregrym).

There is so much I love about this series. Labine is fantastic and hilarious as Sam's sidekick. He makes being funny look effortless. He's one of my favorite characters on TV.  Wise is pitch-perfect as the Devil. You know he's bad and you shouldn't find him entertaining but you won't be able to help yourself.

As thoroughly entertaining and fun as the show is, what's still sort of missing is that overarching plot that would make the series appointment television. The show needs to become more than just capturing the demon of the week. I want to see more about what the Devil is up to? How exactly the man Sam thought was his father fits into all of this? The stakes need to be raised all around. I never really think Sock, Ben, Sam or Andi are in real danger because they never really are.

We will see Marino, Black, and Sam's "father" again this season. Both Ben and Sock will embark on romances and we know Andi and Sam can't be happy for too long. This all bodes well. Because as much as I truly enjoy the series, I keep thinking it could be even better. It's on the precipice of going from being a good series to being a great one. And I'm confident, given the opportunity to come into its own, it will get there.

Are you excited for the second season premiere of Reaper? Talk about it below. And after you watch Tuesday's premiere, let me know what you think.

24

We are all in complete agreement that Sean is the most boring bad guy Jack has ever faced. He couldn't even muster up any energy around his treachery. Honestly I'm more fired up when I go shopping and forget my coupons.

We all knew there had to be a mole in the FBI. He seemed like the most obvious choice and he was blah, blah, blah. Sure it was fun little surprise that Erika (Ever Carradine) turned out to be a traitor too but you knew Sean was going to kill her for the moment the episode began. Also I think the series didn't build up the Erika enough before they killed her off. I wasn't invested enough in her character at all.

But here's the good news -- Sean is no where to be found in tonight's two-hour 24 episode (Monday, FOX, 8 p.m.). It appears that the series might be unceremoniously done with him. And frankly I don't care if we never find out why he betrayed his country. Really who cares?

And here's the even better news about tonight's two-hour extravaganza. It. Is. So. Good. I am so back into the 24 fold. The episode is the kind of edge-of-my-seat, pillow-over-my-eyes stressful episode the show is famous for. A lot happens tonight and I wouldn't ruin a second of it by telling you too much. But here's what I can talk about. The series seems to be on a huge "the ends justify the means" kick. Basically the show is saying that Jack's way of torturing people to get the information he needs leads to a greater good. If this season was about making Jack account for his actions, the series seems to be saying he doesn't need to. The facts speak for themselves. Let Jack do what he needs to save the world or suffer the consequences. Is this a good message to be sending? No but I'm also not looking for 24 to set the moral tone for real life domestic and international conflicts. I'm looking at 24 to be entertaining, exciting television which it really is. Jack is a conflicted, renegade hero, a complicated good guy who goes deeper and deeper into the dark side with each passing season.

I take 24 for what it is -- a scripted fictional series. Just like I don't think parents should take parenting tips from the ladies of Wisteria Lane and if the doctors I go to are behaving like the doctors on Private Practice I don't want to know about it, I'm hoping no one is looking to Jack Bauer on how to handle prisoners of war, acts of treason or threats to national security.

Here's what's great about tonight -- we get to see more of Agent Aaron Pierce, one of my all time favorite 24 characters. Jon Voight, who we last saw in the Redemption movie, returns. Renee (Annie Wersching) continues to be a fantastic character for this series -- she's got moxie and a lot of heart. Whatever Renee's fate turns out to be on 24, my guess is that we'll see a lot more of Wersching on TV. She's the discovery of the season.

I know a lot of you think Janis (Janeane Garofalo) is a poor man's Chloe. My take is that she's supposed to be -- come on no one can be Chloe! But what she does provide for Chloe and to the series is an appropriate foil for Chloe. Chloe has met her match from a technological standpoint in Janis. And it's kind of fun to watch a character out-Chloe Chloe.

All this is to say, that I think tonight's episode is simply fantastic. I'm ready to go all in on the seventh season of 24. Are you?

Highlights of the Week Ahead

All times listed are Eastern Standard Time for March 2-8

CBS comedies are all new tonight (hooray!). Romance blooms but not for whom you think on The Big Bang Theory (Monday, CBS, 8 p.m.). For a look at tonight's episode click here.

You can finally see Frances Conroy as Barney's mother on How I Met Your Mother (Monday at 8:30 p.m. on CBS).

You all know that I haven't been the biggest fan of Saving Grace, which returns with new episodes (Monday,TNT, 10 p.m.) I just never really connected with Holly Hunter's gritty, troubled, feisty detective or the fact that she regularly converses with an angel named Earl. But tonight's episode definitely intrigued me. Christina Ricci joins the cast for four episodes as Grace's new partner. The dynamic between Ricci and Hunter is an exciting addition to the series. I'm still not the show's biggest fan but for the first time, I kind of want to see what happens next.

Who are you hoping the judges bring back for the wild card round on American Idol (Thursday, FOX, 8 p.m.). I'm pulling for Anoop Desai, Jasmine Murray and Matt Breitzke -- all of whom I think made really bad song choices. During the Wild Card round, the judges will decided live which three contestants will become part of the top 12. I'm not going to lie to you. I'm a little nervous.

Okay let's take a little break from our bedside vigil of Dr. Carter to talk about what's happening on ER (Thursday, NBC, 10 p.m.). I loved that Dr. Carter's old school ways still prevailed in some cases and his scene where he jokingly told Dr. Banfield he came for her kidney was a great flashback to the Carter we knew and loved. Just like I loved when he asked Sam how Abby and Luka were doing. Noah Wyle only has two more episodes left (including this week's) and next week he'll be visited by an old friend. I don't know if I'm suffering from an overwhelming case of nostalgia or what but I'm totally panicking that there are only five more episodes of ER left. Also I have a question for those of you who don't want Neela with Ray. I'm okay with that but you don't want her with Simon do you? I wish the show wasn't spending so many of its precious final minutes on their relationship.

So what did you think of the two-hour Brothers & Sisters event? Are you annoyed that ABC kept saying there would be a shocking death and no one died (unless they were talking about the death of Robert and Kitty's marriage that is). I do like Robert's blind ambition in spite of his family obligations and his own personal health. I believe a man who ran for President would still want more politically. And, as I've said, whatever the reasons behind the Tommy storyline might be, I still think it's a good story line for the series. It makes sense to me that Tommy would want to reclaim his family business by whatever means necessary. What did you think of the episode? Talk about it below.

That's all for today. I'm back on Wednesday with this week's familiar faces, thoughts on The United States of Tara and more. Also coming this week, a look at Friday Night Lights (subtitled: why I love Tim Riggins). Have a question? Seen a familiar face? Want to nominate a quote of the week? Write me at amytvgal@zap2it.com. Talk to you on Wednesday.


38 Comments

Excellent column, Amy!! Of course, the fact that you talked about one of my most favorite tv shows (24) and gave a great review of another (Reaper) makes it easy for me to love! :o)

I'm so silly with excitement for Reaper's return! Tyler Labine is just the best and this show is such a fun escape!

I'm still no fan of Janis, but hey, I'm dealing with it and coming to terms that she may be around for the whole season. Especially based on an interview I saw with Janeane Garofalo about her choice of wardrobe on the show.

Sean makes oatmeal look exciting. You're totally true. I have no need to even hear about how or why he became a traitor. Unless it has to do with his wife and why she was in Vegas... hmmm... I think I overthink 24 sometimes! LOL


I also like the Tommy storyline on B&S. Tommy is definatley the type to confuse family pirde ect with money and power. And it completely makes sense that Holly would not let it go.

I like where this is going.


I loved the Brothers and Sisters episode, it moved all the major story lines forward without being too over the top...and technically Robert DID die, they were able to revive him...I am also enjoying the last episodes of ER...and I can't wait to see how they work all the special guest stars in....LOVE your column..


Love reaper can't wait.

24 is better this year than it has been over the past 2 or so. I am not loving Rene, she pales next to Chase or Curtis as a partner.


I Think that Renee is going to make Jack see what he does in a different light. Every episode, she gets him to take a step back and evaluate what they are doing. She is slowly getting at him and by seasons end, I think Jack will be a different man.


I am so ticked off that a stupid basketball game is on CW this Tuesday! I could care less about basketball. Give me Reaper. NOW!


AMY: I agree with you about Reaper. I love the comedy, especially Tyler Labine. The only thing that's missing is a sense of urgency...maybe it's time for an unexpected death? I think Joss Whedon did a better job at combining humor and an overarching plot during his days at BtVS and Angel. Let's hope Reaper gets a 3rd season!

I also agree with you about '24'. I consider every season of this show like another sequel to an action movie franchise. Jack Bauer is like America's version of James Bond. You have to suspend your disbelief that Jack can save millions of people's lives, while surviving gunshot wounds, explosions, etc. I hate the torture scenes, too, but I don't think this show should be considered a do***entary on how the United States actually handles prisoners of war and terrorists.

By the way, I was one of the readers who coined Janis as a "Poor Woman's Chloe O'Brian". I hope that Janis is a one season character because she is as annoying as Sean is BORING!

I don't like the idea of the judges choosing 3 Wild Cards to make it to the final 12 on American Idol. I hate that 25% of this year's finalists will be chosen by 4 judges, and not the 20+ millions viewers of this show. I have a feeling that they will pick Megan and Matt Giraud as the Wild Cards, and then probably another girl. Unfortuately, I think they will leave out Anoop (whom I really liked, too), who barely lost the 3rd finalist spot to Michael Sarver. :-(


Hey Amy, in the AMERICAN IDOL paragraph, I think you don't want the "d" on decided, right?

As for AI, I want Meagan Corkrey instead of Matt though, she was so much more interesting. Of course we haven't seen who's gonna be likeable and not going through this week.

As for Brothers and Sisters, I haven't formed my opinions yet. However, how only Sally Field and sometimes Rachel Griffiths are the only actors being recognized by the biased award-giving bodies is beyond me. They deserve more acting awards and nominations. The show absolutely deserves acting awards and nominations.


I believe that the DEATH on B&S was Robert flatlining after his heart attack. Technically, he was dead. I watch Daytime TV and the magazines pull this DEATH crap with people just flatlining for a moment all the time.


A real hoot is that Roger R Cross, who played Curtis Manning on 24, is now playing Sunset Boulevard, a straight man female impersonator on The L Word who is in love with Kit. Now that's range.


Post a comment

 optional
 optional
 
Find it fast

Zap2it on Facebook
twitter Zap2it Twitter Talk
Recent posts