TV Gal

Out of the Land of Denial . . . Accepting Reality TV

By Amy Amatangelo

   |  

July 2, 2008 12:13 PM ET

Pumkin_ilovemoney_240 Here's my problem: I keep waiting for the reality TV craze to bottom out.

Credit naiveté. Blind faith in TV viewers everywhere. Or all that quality time I spend in the land of denial.

But every time I hear about a new, unsettling reality show (for instance The Baby Borrowers), I think to myself, "Well it can't possibly get worse than that," I remember when Who Wants to Marry a Multi-Millionaire? debuted in 2000, I thought no one would watch it. But they did. And it spawned off-spring like Joe Millionaire. I mean can you imagine that The Bachelor is still going strong six years after it first debuted? By my count, the show has only resulted in one marriage.

But the network that seems to relish/wallow in the reality TV craze is VH-1, which has completely reinvented itself as the place "stars" go to expose their life to uncomfortable and often pathetic levels.

I date the problem back to the year 2004 when The Surreal Life moved from the WB to the music network. And I'll admit I was part of the problem because I did watch most of that season that starred Charo, Dave Coulier, Flavor Flav, Jordan Knight, Brigitte Nielsen, and Ryan Starr. That show kicked off Flavor Flav's TV career and Strange Love and Flavor of Love soon followed.

Midgetmac_ilovemoney_240 And now comes I Love Money, which premieres Sunday at 9 p.m. on VH-1. In this series, 17 contestants from I Love New York, Flavor of Love, and Rock of Love travel to Mexico to compete for $250,000. Backstabbing ensues and, no surprise, there's a stripper pole involved in some of the challenges and something called the Spit Olympics. It sounds a little like a raunchier version (how scary is that?) of The Real World/Road Rules challenge.

In a way I admire the honesty of the show. Obviously these contestants value money over everything else. But I think this is the show that is going to do it for me. I now accept that reality TV will probably never bottom out. That there are new and more heinous shows to come.

How about you? Is there a show that made you realize that TV has no rock bottom? That there will always be people willing to expose themselves to increasing degrees of humiliation for their proverbial 15 minutes of fame and fleeting fortune.

And if you want a sneak peak at what I'm talking about episode one is now available on VH1.com

The Emmys

Since we had such a healthy debate about this year's Amy Awards (to vote None of the Above or not, that is the question), I thought this would be a super fabulous time to talk about the Emmy Awards.

Sandraoh_greysanatomy_s3_240 The nominees will be announced on Thursday, July 17, but for the first time, the Academy of Television Arts and Sciences has announced the ten comedies and dramas that are in contention for a nomination. So we already know that How I Met Your Mother has no chance of being nominated for Best Comedy but Pushing Daisies does. We won't see Brothers & Sisters on the best drama list but we could see Grey's Anatomy. For the complete list, click here.

What do you think about this idea? Should the Academy let people know who is contention weeks before the nominations? Do the Emmys at all influence what you watch? Have the Emmy Awards let you down so much over the years (no Gilmore Girls, no Buffy the Vampire Slayer, no Veronica Mars) that you no longer hold out hope that your favorite shows will be nominated?

Talk about the Emmy Awards below.

Where Have I Seen Them Before?

Erniehudson_108_240 Jeanine recognized Ernie Hudson as the psychiatrist on The Secret Life of the American Teenager. Hudson was, of course, Winston Zeddemore in Ghostbusters. He was also Warden Leo Glynn on Oz, Detective Ridley on Desperate Housewives, and Gus' dad on Psych.

And many of you correctly recognized Shailene Woodley, Amy on TSLOTAT (like Jeanine, I too think the title is too long, we simply must use the acronym). Woodley was the original Kaitlin on The OC (before she went from child to teenage vixen). She was also the young Jordan on Crossing Jordan. Mark Derwin, Amy's father, was Dr. Mark Molloy on Life with Bonnie and Sam Gordon on Heist. Josie Bissett, Jane on Melrose Place, was Grace's mom. But most importantly I simply must know what you thought about the show. You all have been suspciously silent about it. Did you not watch? Or are you still in shock?

Sherry Stringfield was the woman in witness protection whose husband was cheating on In Plain Sight. She was, of course, Dr. Susan Lewis on ER and we saw her most recently as Rita in Tell Me You Love Me. Virginia Williams was the woman the husband was having the affair with. She was Claudia the woman getting married when Ted met Victoria (Ashley Williams) on How I Met Your Mother and she was the runaway bride in a episode of Veronica Mars.

Indira Varma was the woman who was at the center of an assassination attempt on Law & Order: Criminal Intent. She was Niobe on Rome and Dr. Adrianne Holland on 3lbs.

TV Gal Schedule

Jeffreydonovan_gabrielleanwar_burnn Just a programming note to let you know that I won't have a column this Friday, July 4 or on Monday, July 7. But I will be back on Wednesday July 9 with a review of the second season premiere of Burn Notice and the new CBS series Flashpoint (Keith Mars returns!).

That's all for today. I hope you have a wonderful 4th of July. Have a question? Seen a familiar face? Want to nominate a quote of the week? Write me at amytvgal@zap2it.com. Talk to you next Wednesday.

 
 
Zap2it Elite Sheet Must Reads from the Web's In-Crowd
 

I used to be a big fan of Survivor, but I stopped a few years back. The only reality TV show I watch now is Top Chef and Dirty Jobs. I still watch the Mole because I loved the first season of it many years ago, but I probably won't watch another season of that either.

I finally watched TSLOTAT (even the acronym is long) last night, and I didn't love it, but I am willing to give it a chance to become watchable.

I loathe reality tv, so in the summer, I try anything scripted--and I think Swingtown really hit its stride with last week's episode. TSLOTAT could become less wooden as the writers and actors get to know the characters better.

The main girl's BFFs make me want to die, though. The girl from Still Standing, in particular. Really, no one thinks of the free clinic or Planned Parenthood? Really, you want her to pretend the baby is someone else's?

The only reality show I have watched recently is groomer has it. it just is not my type of television--so I do not watch as much TV now especially in the summer when it almost all reality shows. What happened to playing the reruns in the summer? It seems like Fox and CBS are the only ones who do this any more and they do not do it much

I am also extremely sick of reality TV. I can put up with some of it, in fact, I watch some of it. ("American Idol", "The Mole"...) I am not against reality TV itself, but I am strongly against stupid reality TV. Unfortuntely, most reality shows fall under that category. Things like "The Baby Borrowers" also makes me sick...it makes me even more sick to see that people actually watch this stuff!

'Secret Life' was better than I'd anticipated. It was, like Amy said last week, *very* predictable, but that's not necessarily a bad thing. It was really good to see Molly Ringwald again.

I wondered about a free clinic too, and why no one thought of that. I guess we're supposed to think that they didn't know, being only 15.

So, I'm going to grant this show my usual three strikes. If I'm not at least somewhat emotionally invested after 3 episodes, I'm done.

I have to say that I watched TSLOTAT and hated it. I mean I used to watch 7th heaven the first few season and enjoyed but then had to turn it off because it just became too sugary sweet for me but this show was sweetness squared. I might give it another chance but it was just bad....

I have no idea what TSLOTAT stands for. Maybe Amy could have one of those legends in the corner to keep us all up to date. Too may abbreviations to keep up with for this ole dog.

re: The Emmys -> I never thought it was a true indication of what the best TV was, b/c I realized very early on (yes I am very cynical) but it was in fact what was the best among the most popular on tv at that particular time - with a few notable exceptions. eg. Arrested Development. The Golden Globes are usually a little better, but they too far to often ignore the truly best stuff on tv. Buffy, Veronica Mars, Gilmore Girls, The Wire, OZ, Scrubs.

The Moment of Truth is such an awful show. To think people are willing to put themselves and their loved ones through such crap for money (or not) is shameful. And then people watch it!!!?

Reality shows suck.

They are televisions version of fast food: cheap to produce, tasteless and yet millions of lazy, brain dead Americans consume them.

I wish someone in the industry had the guts to address the terrible impact it's having on the television medium (less quality scripted programming) and its effect on our society (young viewers watching people behaving poorly and doing very stupid, bad things).

Ugh. What's happened to TV. So sad.

Post a comment

Find it fast
Most talked about posts
Zap2it on Facebook
Zap2it Twitter Talk
Recent posts