It Happened Last Night

'American Idol's' Hollywood Week a 'Sweet Escape' for Alex Lambert and 70 others

By Andrea Reiher

   |  

February 10, 2010 10:12 PM ET

american-idol-hollywood-week-group-night-320.jpgHollywood Week sees "American Idol" lose 25 contestants to the dreaded Group Day.

Oh, happy day! Group Day! I am so ready for the crazy drama of the groups. Since this episode is all over the place, the recap is not chronological. It's divided up by group.

Mary Powers, Alex Lambert, Margo May, Hope Johnson and Erin Hundley form the Dreamers. Hope and Erin really insert themselves into the group without being asked, then disappear for awhile. Eventually they get started but they keep fighting and Mary is being really pushy and bossy, even with the vocal coach. Mary eventually yells at Alex, calling him the weakest link.

When they finally perform as the last group of the day, after Group Nazi Mary's reign of tyranny, their "Dreams" is rough. Mary does alright, Hope is weak and thin, Margo is ... my God, how did that girl get a Golden Ticket, we don't see Erin and Alex Lambert sways like he's some kind of savant and he's counting prime numbers in his head. Mary, Hope and Alex make it through and Erin and Margo are cut. 

Maddie Penrose, Danny Jones, Mark Labriola, Tori Kelly and Kim Kerbow are the Mighty Rangers. Maddie and Kim want to rehearse late into the night and the other three want to go to bed. When they perform "Closer," Tori and Maddie are good, but Mark and Kim totally blow the words. We aren't shown Danny, but he gets cut along with Kim and Mark. Wow, Danny Jones looks like Michael Jackson (not in a good way). Mark begs for another chance, which is kind-of gross. I get that you're sad, but you blew an amazing chance. People would die to get how far you got and you need to suck it up.

Jermaine Sellers, Ben Honeycutt, Jeff Goldford, Cat Nessle and Moorea Masa (the girl from Danny Gokey's group last year) are the Phoenix group. Moorea is trying to push for more harmonies, but the group isn't having it. Man, I'd listen to her. Her group was tight last year. They eventually get yelled at by the vocal coach for not being prepared.

Their meltdown comes the next day when they are ready to perform and Cat Nessle quits on the spot. Geez, girl. They perform "Carry On Wayward Son" and everybody flubs the words, which always mystifies me. You've had time to learn the words, plus it's a well-known song! Jermaine also lets loose with a squeal that the audience cheers for, but I didn't think sounded that nice. Simon doesn't want to hear about their "struggles" and neither do I. Ben and Moorea are cut. To her credit, Moorea immediately hugs her group members who made it. I love to see good sportsmanship like that. 

Neapolitan is made up of Paige Miles, Thaddeus Johnson, Jessica Cunningham and Liz Rooney. They're doing "Bad Romance." Also doing that song is Destiny's Wild, which includes Siobhan Magnus, Jareb Liewer, Theri and Todrick Hall. The two groups are in a bit of a "Bad Romance" rivalry. They should rumble, "West Side Story" style. When Neapolitan performs, Jessica stands out for me, both vocally and because of her very orange skin -- lay off the tanning bed, Jess. The judges love it and put them all through.  

Destiny's Wild doesn't like that Neapolitan "stole" their idea of doing the song acapella. Hmmm. I'm pretty sure the idea of doing a song acapella pre-dates "American Idol" by several hundreds of years. Let's not get our panties in a twist, DW. When they perform, they blow Neapolitan away, so I don't know what they were so upset about it. The judges love it (though Ellen calls it "weird," which I think is a bit rich considering it's a Lady Gaga song) and put them all through.

Mike Lynche, Michael Castro, Tim Urban and Seth Rollins are Team Awesome and they are the first group done for the night. Mike goes off to talk to his wife (who is in labor). Right before performing the next day, Mike gets to listen on the phone while she gives birth to their daughter. That's very cool. They do "Get Ready" and it's rough. Not terrible, but not great. Only Big Mike and Tim Urban make it through.

Faith is made up of Ashley Rodriguez, Michelle Delamor and Charity Vance with "Irreplaceable" and it's very good. They should all go through and they do! Good.

There's a montage of "Sweet Escape," which is a difficult song lyrically, but everybody gets up and flubs the words. And not just minor flubs -- we're talking gibberish. Why would you pick such a rhythmically and lyrically difficult song? It's like picking a more musical "It's the End of the World As We Know It." 

Big Dreams is made up of Matt Lawrence, Amanda Shectman and two other dudes and they flub "Sweet Escape" both lyrically and musically so they are all sent home. Bummer about Matt, but I didn't think Amanda wasn't anything to write home about. She also won't stop crying. [eye roll]

Other people sent home are Leah Laurenti, Carmen Turner, Kimberly Carver and Dave Pittman. I only get broken up over Leah Laurenti and by "broken up" I mean, "give a passing thought to."

Middle C with Janell Wheeler, Jermaine Purifory and Casey James does "Closer" and really nails it. I am particularly blown away by Casey James in Hollywood (in comparison to his initial audition, which I didn't love).

Three Men and a Baby with Andrew Garcia, Katie Stevens, J.B. Ahfua and one other dude (who is that?) do "No One" and it's great. All of Middle C and Three Men and a Baby get through.

More people who made it: John Park, Haeley Vaughn, Angela Martin, Tasha Layton, Tyler Grady, Katelyn Epperly, Lloyd Thomas, Keia Johnson and Christian Spear.

We find out that only 25 people were cut. Um, what? You put them through all the group shenanigans and only cut 25 people? That sucks.

What did you guys think? Really broken up about anybody in particular who got cut?

Follow Zap2it Andrea on Twitter and follow Zap2it on Twitter and Facebook for the latest movies, TV and celebrity news


Related:

Did 'America's Got Talent' reach out to Howard Stern?
The PTC wants to keep 'Idol' safe from Howard Stern
FOX40's Paul Robins balks at Howard Stern
Howard Stern responds to 'American Idol' rumors '


Photo credit: FOX


 
 
 
Zap2it Elite Sheet Must Reads from the Web's In-Crowd
 

Yikes! No comments yet?

I missed the very beginning and am wondering how the groups chose their songs. Did they get to chose or were they randomly drawn from a hat or such?

Couldn't they have given the groups room to practice where they weren't all on top of each other?

The episode was kind of overwhelming, there was so much going on.

Kinda sad to see Seth Rollins go...he is the guy that has the autistic son.

looks like the producers are already calling favourties by the amount of airtime given per the leaked top 24 list. that sucks, but i just have to remember allison from last year who got zero airtime.

very badly handled
why did some groups have to sing that GWen Stefan song with all that patter
everyone should have had to have done it then.
If Gwen Stefani got on a stage and had to sing that without music it would sound awful
VERY UNFAIR
some people should not have been cut
lousy show last night
very uneven

Selena D, I'm 99% sure the groups are given a list of songs of choose from, so whichever groups thought "Sweet Escape" was a good idea brought all that trouble on themselves. : )

UGH! The producers are doing a terrible job of editing so far. There are too many contestants at this point, and their jumpy editing doesn't help us figure out who is who.

@The world: I haven't read the leaked top 24 list, but I know from watching past seasons that TPTB definitely give more screen time to their early favorites. The producers like to give the contestants with sad sob stories the most time, so that's why we saw very little of Allison Iraheta and Kris Allen before last year's semi-finals round (they didn't have any "tragic" backstory). :-(

JMO, but I wasn't too impressed with anyone from the Neapolitan group. I preferred the version of "Bad Romance" done by Destiny's Wild, and I thought their performance was appropriate for a Lady Gaga song! I also liked the Faith group, and I was glad to see Andrew, Jermaine, Casey and Katie make it through as well.

I don't understand why anyone would want to perform that "Sweet Escape" song with a group when there is so much potential for disaster. There are a lot of lyrics to memorize, and it's not like the song would show off anyone's range. I was turned off by Mark Labriola's begging and Mary Powers' bossy attitude! In fact, I was surprised that more people weren't cut from this episode. By the way, I was wondering why they haven't shown Michael Castro that much. I read that he was very sick before Hollywood week, so that's probably why we weren't shown his performances, not even his part in Team Awesome! :-(

What happened to the police officer and the foster homes kid? I couldn't tell if they were in the going on or going home shots.

I have never unstood the concept of Group Day. All AI winners are soloists. They compete doing solos. They are judged individually, yet they are supposed to get together with people with whom they have never worked with before and crank out an act for the judges. And the judging is based on what - how they worked together? No - it's how they blended into a group that they will never have to be in again if they move on. Ridiculous premise for a show based solely on solo performances.

@Selena D -- Andrea's correct. They get a list of available songs and make the choice themselves. If the producers were doing it, either everyone would do a different song or they'd all do the same.

And Andrea, I had the same thought at the end of the night about so few people being cut. Seems like it's going to make this last stage even harder on both contestants and judges.

I always read Andrea and all the comments. Keep them coming (I'm not much of a commentator myself).

Post a comment

Find it fast
Zap2it Twitter Talk
Recent posts