'The Office': Michael Scott, the last honest man
Well now. Thursday's "Office" presented what could be a very interesting direction for the show. Namely: What happens when Michael Scott becomes disillusioned with Dunder Mifflin?Given his celebratory mood after being able to score the limo for the ride back to Scranton, I don't think it's going to set in just yet. But it has to be coming, because even someone as naive as Michael would have to realize that the people above him A) are full of crap about the company's prospects and B) don't seem to care all that much. These are the same folks who made Ryan a VP, after all.
Whenever this dawns on him, I think it will be kind of great, and I also think the fact that DM Scranton is still profitable combined with Jim's supermarket idea from last week will be what ends up saving at least their branch's bacon. But until then, if the show keeps delivering more episodes like this one, I shall be one happy recapper.
Steve Carell did a spin on vintage tone-deaf Michael in "Shareholders Meeting," but in a rare and rather inspired changeup to the usual formula, he was mostly in the right. Yes, he was talking out of his butt when he told the angry shareholders that things would be OK. And yes, he gave into his burning need to be liked and shouted half-cocked thoughts about a plan to save the company when there was none.
But didn't the spectacle of seeing CEO types (and a former congressman now cashing in with a seat on the board) get booed and jeered just feel kinda good? Maybe the show was laying it on a bit heavy with the tone-deafness of the Dunder Mifflin higher-ups -- the limo sent to pick Michael up, the swanky hospitality suite, the bodyguards -- but I'm OK with that. As a stand-in for every arrogant, bailout-taking, bonus-justifying captain of industry in the real world, it was just satisfying to watch Dunder Mifflin CEO Alan Brand get his.
The show also found the funny in the situation, though, coming mostly from Michael's cluelessness about being used as a pawn in the corporate game. His failure to cover his microphone, the way he riled up the crowd, his inability to see why Oscar wouldn't want to stick his neck out in front of the bigwigs -- all of it clicked. My favorite bit? His voiceover as the camera followed him, Dwight, Oscar and Andy sprinting toward the limo: "The perks? I could take or leave the perks. But limos are for people who make the company money, not lose millions and have no plan. So we're leaving early."
Other notes from "Shareholders Meeting":
- With as involved (and good) a main story as we had tonight, the B plot didn't have to do much, but Jim's mini-standoff with Ryan worked pretty well. Their sort-of rivalry hasn't surfaced much since Ryan's demotion, but it seems pretty natural that Ryan would be doing little things to undermine Jim -- like sending an e-mail to everyone saying Jim didn't have the same authority as Michael. Jim's not entirely sure he does either, but putting the little d-bag in his place in his new closet/office was a nice little reminder of the pecking order.
- Loved, loved the entire branch's negative reaction to Michael's twirl: "Lose the twirl ... the twirl sucks ... I hated the twirl ..." capped by Andy, in his P.A.-announcer voice: "Hate the twirl!"
- Pam, after a late hand-raise in support of Jim having the same amount of managerial power as Michael: "I forgot I have to support him no matter what. Close one."
- No real Creed moment this week, sadly. His only scene came with Ryan, who was dishing out romantic advice. Ah well.
Zap2it Elite Sheet Must Reads from the Web's In-Crowd
Post a comment
Most talked about posts
Advertisement
Zap2it Twitter Talk
Recent posts
Great cold opening with Recyclops.
I thought the recyclops bit was terrible. Didn't even crack a smile. It was bad.
As for the main story, i thought the entire show was very weak. It would have improved greatly, if Oscar would have spoken up and given him his opinion and his take on things. It would have been a better story if Oscar saved the day and gave ideas that they could have used. It would have been a good dynamic to see Oscar promoted above Michael.
And as much as I despise the Michael character, I really thought he had a good idea about the 45 steps, with step 45 being the company is solvent again, and working his way back from that.
I would have been totally okay with Michael coming up with the ideas to save the company and appease the crowd of share holders and employees.
It would have been perfect to promote Michael up the ladder, thus leaving the Scranton branch entirely in Jim's hands as the sole manager of the branch.
It would have given the show the needed jolt.
Plus Michael could have continued to make his office in Scranton and interfered with Jim's efforts.
What? Michael Scott was an amazing people person in this episode!
M.S.: "So have you ever guarded anyone famous?"
Guard: "I'm not supposed to talk about stuff like that. Nelly Furtado."
M.S.: "I'm not the moron. You... you're... the moron."
Ryan: "Do I get the internet here? Hello?"
DMI stock is down 6.9 points to $1.1. (As the Scranton gang "waves goodbye" to the meeting.)
And that facepalm moment at the end, when Dwight gets the crowd behind him... only for them to realize it was Dwight.
It was the worst episode in what has become the worst season of the show. This show is supposed to be a comedy, there were no laughs last night. I have no idea where they are going with this plot line. The early seasons displayed situations that were realistic, but exaggerated to make them funnier. Nothing about this episode was realistic.
Really poor episode beginning w/ the totally unfunny Dwight recyclops thing. The "Michael is DM's best manager" thread is really getting lame. If Michael is DMI's best, then the CEOs ARE morons and DMI should go belly up. I think this show has run its course.
I, also was uninspired by this latest episode. I don't get what the recapper thought was so great.
When watching DVDs of past seasons I realize that this show MAY have peaked already... and the best could be behind us.
It is a sad day.
Those that don't find this show funny are CSI fans.
Great Epi.
It was a pretty great episode, not gonna lie. But The Office has to end this year. It's jumped the shark, and it's time for an end so it can save itself.
It's just a TV show, people. It doesn't have to be 100% realistic, but it's still hilarious. If you don't see the comedy, then you are retarded. The writers/actors do quite well with the subtle comedy. You often have to rewatch each scene to catch every reaction and every detail in the background.
Why can't you just enjoy the show for as long as it lasts? Stop complaining about something that's not under your control. It's actually fairly realistic for a company to not change much at a branch if it's out-performing every other branch. Money talks.