It Happened Last Night

'Top Chef: Las Vegas': Best. Restaurant Wars. Ever.

By Hanh Nguyen

   |  

October 22, 2009 10:09 AM

rickmoonen_padmalakshmi_topcheflasvegas_290.jpgWednesday night's Restaurant Wars episode of "Top Chef: Las Vegas" showed those other five seasons how it should be done. Now I'm a fan.

Don't get me wrong: I love me some "Top Chef." For some reason though, it seemed like everyone except for me loved the Restaurant Wars episodes. I always felt it was always too much of a disaster, too unrealistic, too much like "Hell's Kitchen" for me to enjoy completely.

Quickfire Challenge

The Vegas edition of Restaurant Wars was different, however. Let's just start with the brilliant and maddening Quickfire Challenge, which was by no means realistic, yet the chefs actually delivered what looked to be elegant, tasty and well-plated food.

In the Tag Team Cookoff, the remaining eight chef'testants broke up into two teams. Each team of four would get 40 minutes total -- 10 minutes apiece -- to cook part of and eventually plate a dish. The twist? There were two: No discussion of the dish would take place between the contestants, and those teammates waiting for their turn would be blindfolded.

Yeah ... I think Kevin called it "ludicrous" more than once.

jennifer_topcheflasvegas-290.jpgI gotta give props to both teams: Jennifer's team consisting of Laurine, Mike Isabella and Kevin and M. Voltaggio's team consisting of his brother, Eli and the dreaded mother hen Robin. They really do know their food and were able to puzzle out, improvise and sometimes even change the flavor profile/plan that was implemented. That was really something to watch.

Team Jennifer won with the sable fish dish, winning $10K for the team. Evil Padma the enabler offered them the chance to let it ride -- if they won Restaurant Wars, each team member would get $10K apiece. Otherwise, nada. They made the devil's choice.

Restaurant Wars: Team Mission

Chef Rick Moonen graciously allowed the chef'testants to cook and serve at his RM Seafood at Mandalay Bay, which meant -- woo hoo! -- no decor responsibilities! That always seemed like the silliest and needlessly time-consuming part of Restaurant Wars to me. Sure, a chef must have a vision, a certain aesthetic, but having no design consultants (which even "Hell's Kitchen" provides) and having it cut into food prep time? I call BS.

Oh, and all chefs were told to keep the restaurant's stance on seafood sustainability intact, which meant cooking the right fish. Check out Fish Watch for more.

laurine_topcheflasvegas_290.jpgAnyway, Laurine decided to volunteer for front of the house. Wait, what? She's a total robot-mouse! Gregarious jokester Mike Isabella would have made much more sense. And Laurine was even more dismal than I expected. Timing was completely off in the kitchen, so she totally lost it, running back and forth, losing her food judgment and forgetting to inform the diners (and judges!) of what they were eating. Her one dish -- lamb that she prepped, but Kevin finished -- was lackluster and the meat's temperature was inconsistent.

Everyone else just took on far too much. Mike had two cold dishes (inconsistent arctic char and asparagus), Jennifer had two fish dishes (bland trout with broken butter sauce and Alaskan halibut with mussels and clams), and Kevin had two meat dishes (pork belly and Laurine's lamb).

No lie. The timing was just disastrous from the start, mainly because Jennifer was too ambitious and steamed her shellfish to order. Yikes!

And ... they decided to leave off dessert completely since dessert always spelled Waterloo for previous Restaurant Wars losers.

Restaurant Wars: Team Revolt

michaelvoltaggio_topcheflasvegas_29.jpgOkay, the Voltaggio Brothers -- love 'em or hate 'em -- always make me laugh, especially when they're squabbling. I'm just waiting for the "Stop hitting yourself" or "I'm not touching you!" moments. In particular, Michael's idea to name the restaurant Revolt -- Robin, Eli and Voltaggios -- was hilarious. As Padma so wisely pointed out, "Did they not think we'd think of 'revolting'?" Nope, that was brought up, but they went with Revolt anyway.

Eli went through his "Clark Kent" transformation for the front of the house. His intensity was scary, but at least he was thorough. Since apparently the boys were scared that Robin might eff up the team, they only gave her one dish: a twist on her successful apple tart -- a pear pithivier (yeah, I had to look that up) with an elderflower sauce. Yum!

The Brothers Voltaggio each took on two dishes apiece and executed them splendidly, Michael better than Bryan though. The editing highlighted Michael throughout the episode, which made me fear that he was heading for some sort of comeuppance, but nope, he won. That brilliant-ass chef won again. This is all written with affection though, especially since he showed his true colors when he decided to share his spoils of Restaurant War -- the $10,000 that Team Mission lost by letting it ride -- with his entire team. Good on you, Michael.

Miscellaneous thoughts and musings:

  • Yes, Michael isn't the most self-aware person. He's a bit of a jerk in the kitchen and gets distracted by feelings of superiority. If I knew him in life, I'd probably be annoyed. As it stands though, he did keep the team in order and creates food that lives up to his cocky attitude. The boy can cook.
  • Can the Voltaggio Brothers cook no wrong (forget that other episode)? Just hearing about the chicken and calimari noodles, tender cod and ganache with spearmint ice cream makes we want to go to there.
  • I'm leaning towards Bryan. He's better at keeping his temper and has yet to demonstrate his brother's level of arrogance.
  • robin_topcheflasvegas_290.jpgI'm still waiting for Robin to get kicked off the island. She delivered a good dessert, but really, being with the Voltaggios' team saved her ass.
  • Wow, superstitious much? Deciding not to offer dessert was just chicken. What kind of Top Chef are you?
  • Top quote -- Eli: "[Robin's cooking is] somewhere east of mars in terms of the kind of food we do."
  • Top quote -- Jennifer: "I called my black cod 'trout' on national TV. Awesome."


Next week: Natalie Portman visits, and Mike Isabella practically pees himself. Hmm, we all know she's vegan, so can we be prepared for more quinoa a la the Zooey Deschanel "Top Chef Masters" challenge?

Your thoughts? Agree that Revolt was the best Restaurant Week restaurant ever?


19 Comments

Padma sux.


Now you finally offer a recap of Top Chef this year - the first, and likely only, time they feature, not one but two chefs from the town I live in.
I hope you keep this recap to the end.

I can't remember if it says it under his name but Bryan V's restaurant in Frederick, MD is named Volt as well. Haven't been there yet as it seems fairly upscale but it gets excellent reviews.

I like that Mike was honest enough to say that Bryan was the guy looking out for everyone and he was the instigator. It is interesting to see how as the competition compresses the brothers are more on edge with each other.

I was almost routing against the brothers V, because if that team lost, it would be incomprehensable not to send Robin home based on overall performance. But then when they indicated some problems with Bryans meat being cold I got a little worried and am glad the other team messed up sso badly.

Finally, when the show 1st started I thought that Jennifer was going to win and she may yet. But she seems to be buckling under the pressure somewhat and the most consistantly good and on chef so far would have to be Kevin. My final three prediction right now still might be Mike V, Kevin and Jennifer, though I hope Bryan makes it into the final three.

sorry for the long post, but it's been building up all season.


Yes, are you going to be recapping TC now that it's halfway over or is this a Restaurant Wars special?

Loved the behind-the-scenes snippet where they intercut Michael V's confessional about yelling and arrogance having no place in the kitchen with scenes of his yelling and arrogance in the kitchen.


@sac & @Beth

The Zap2it powers that be nixed the "Top Chef" recaps this season overall, but allow it in special circumstances. Restaurant Wars dialogue was definitely necessary! We'll see if I'll get the green light to recap the rest of the season or if I'll just be back for the finale.

Beth -- Yes, Michael's quote about having the biggest heart after we see all that yelling was priceless!

Sac -- I have to agree with most of your assessments. My final four + honorable mention:

B Voltaggio
M Voltaggio
Jennifer
Kevin
(and HM to Eli)


ha! your final four is Volt. bros, Jen, and Kevin...

not to be mean or anything..but, uh...no surprise there. good thing you waited until now to give it to us. lol!


Chris -- It was obvious from episode 1 that those 4 people were the tops. I only write it now because this is my first recap for the season.

I also put it out there in case anyone wants to argue with me. Do you like anyone better?


Just want to throw my hat in here in case it adds any pull - Zap2it PLEASE allow the Top Chef recaps to continue! I hate having to google around other sites to get a good one.

----

I too observe that Jennifer seems to be buckling. I'm hoping she'll pull it together b/c she's my fave.


I find the Volt brothers hilarious too. They remind me of my 5 grown cousins that argue and compete constantly even though they are supposed to be adults! I bet their mom cringes watching them fight on tv though I'm sure she's proud of them.

You need to keep recaping this show. I can't stand that you don't this year.


Yes, Zap2it PTB, please let the recaps continue-this one was great and this season is getting better by the week. It was probably the best restaurant wars episode even though it was clear pretty early which team was going down. This was also one of my favorite quick fires whether realistic or not. Maybe the chefs need to be very good for it to work as well as it did. Both Robin and Laurine needed to go so it did not matter which went this week as long as the other goes next time.


Yes, more Top Chef recaps please!

I agree with the top four mentioned earlier. Jen is making me nervious though. I really want her to make final four. I think she is a strong female chef, but she's starting to break under the pressure. As for who I'd like to win, preferably Kevin, but if not him, then Bryan.


Post a comment

 optional
 optional
 
Find it fast

Zap2it on Facebook
twitter Zap2it Twitter Talk
Recent posts