It Happened Last Night

'Private Practice': One begins where the other ends

By Kiley McMichael

   |  

February 19, 2009 8:26 PM

Audramcdonald_privatepractice_240It's a one-way ticket back to L.A. for Private Practice after tonight, as we wrap up the last of the three-part crossover event. Addison says goodbye to Seattle, and heads back home to tangle with her brother the himbo, her best friend's hopeless crush on said himbo, and also deliver a hermaphroditic newborn. Whoo, good times.

However, to give the crossover its due, Derek asks Addison to stick around to monitor Jen the stroke mom's baby, and she does to repay the favor of saving Archer's life. Unfortunately, Derek's original mistake during the first surgery snowballs, leading to Jen's death. Addison's showdown with Derek in the OR was the official baton-passing from Addison to Meredith, even if Meredith didn't really want the baton in the end. Have fun with Derek the broken murderer, Mer.

But back to L.A. we go. where Archer recovered from brain surgery very quickly, didn't he? And the brain worms didn't leave any new sense of morality behind, so he's still sleeping with anything that moves, behind Naomi's back. Addison tells him she can't keep his secret, no matter what the Montgomery Party Line is. But she does, at least at first. She finally breaks down and tells Naomi the truth, but Archer has already skipped town.

Charlotte asks Cooper to move in with her, but he refuses. She ends up getting past the situation by sleeping with Archer, beating herself up about it, and telling Cooper, who refuses to let that ruin things, even if he's the guy living with Violet. Charlotte's tough as nails exterior is crumbling, which is sad, because that's what made her interesting. Now she's just flawed.

Violet agrees to co-chair a couples' therapy session with Sheldon. Violet ends up seeing a wife and a husband - from different couples - making out in the stairwell. Sheldon and Violet end up approaching them both, and even though they decide to face their respective spouses and be together at first, the husband ends up reconnecting with his own wife, and the girlfriend finds out during the next session. Her husband leaves the session, saying he's done, but the other remaining couples reconnect. And in the end, so do Violet and Sheldon, finding some kind of middle ground.

And Pete is broken, he says, but his cancer patient who's living in denial is a little more so. And Sam, who called his girlfriend "Naomi" is a little farther down the denial road. Or river. Whatever.

The secondary storyline involved a newborn born with both sets of genitalia. The parents aren't sure whether to assign a gender now, or wait, and face peer and social issues. There's no right answer, but they decide to go along with the original ultrasound, and assign the baby as male - even if genetically, the child has two big X chromosomes and Addison stresses that only 30% of children orient as male. In the end, she tells the parents that she can't do the surgery, and the mother agrees, against the wishes of the dad. The dad walks out, but Naomi, fresh off the pain of Archer's cheating and departure, confronts him. He returns, because he must be a better man than Archer in the end, right?

So the crossover ended with a whimper, but we're left with a fragile Addison. What would we have had if Archer would have died, instead of just leaving, crying that he's just turned into their father? That might have been a more interesting storyline. A certain peace was made with Derek, and now we're left now with Addison all alone. No SWAT team dude, no rival sexy doctor, nada.

But then, there's always Pete, the original Private Practice fling object.

Nah.

Thoughts...

  • The ABC PR machine is working overtime lately. We had the crossover, or whatever it ended up being, since this evening's crossover finale was a bit of a whimper. But Kate Walsh is on a bunch of magazine covers right now. Eleventh hour despair? Hmmm.

  • "Storming the frickin' castle!" Nice line, Cooper! I'm a sucker for a good Princess Bride reference.

  • Man, I know it's not my show, but Faye Dunaway! No wire hangers ever Faye Dunaway! Get out of my OR, Faye Dunaway!


15 Comments

Frustrated, much?

But yeah. The show feels all over the place these days.


As much as I enjoyed this episode, and I really did, especially getting more insight into Addison's background and seeing her conflict over her family/friendships etc., and as much as I really felt the Charlotte/Cooper throwdown, seriously, what is Shonda Rhimes obsession with cheating and adultery? Not every person ever cheats on someone... it's like a plague that runs through both of her shows. Enough with the cheating... can some people just try to make a relationship work?


Yes, I am frustrated. I find myself groaning while trying to recap. And yes, that's coming through, but I think I'm like a lot of viewers.


Compared with the very boring GA episode before, and the very boring, poorly written, episodes with Cooper pseudo medical cases, this was gold.


No one mentioned that Anya from Buffy played the mom of the baby. Nice to see her.


Tawnya, THANK YOU! I couldn't place her, and then forgot to google it.


Wasn't the cheating husband on Angel?


JC, the cheating husband was on "Heroes"; he played the husband of Ali Larter's confused (and confusing) character. "Heroes" got me too frustrated to watch and lost me from the 2nd season. I think "PrP" is on the same way!!! :-(


Like I said on my Grey's comment - this show seems unable to hold its own. A pity, I was hoping that Grey'd spin-off would be as good - but this one is just another soap opera. As for the herma-baby - Did they not check if the child has a uterus..?? THAT should tell them the designated gender - even if it had both genitalia - or am I missing something here..??


I actually vastly prefer the fragile, all alone Addison we got to the melodrama and prolonged grieving that would have occured if Archer had died. Grief is fairly predictable on TV but I think there's more ways they can go with this if they go with it. I'm curious if she'll just shove all her feelings into another little box like she did after the divorce and be fine by the next episode or if she'll actually deal with any of it this time.

I'm surprised there wasn't any mention of Addie and Archer's fight in his office. The nasty side that scene showed of their dynamic was very telling to me though not that surprising in retrospect. The way she jerked away from where he'd grabbed her and quietly walked out, then when I realized later it had worked when she lied for him was really sad. I hope Archer comes back at some point though. I love the insights into Addie's past he brings. They really are emphasizing this season why 'I love yous' don't mean much to Addison.

Addison shoving that girl out the door at the beginning was hilarious.

Other than the Addie scenes though, I share your frustration with this show. It's just so unfocused. It's actually more like two shows- there's the Addison show with all her issues and family and her best friend Naomi and Nae's ex Sam that I usually like. Then there's the Violet show with all of her drama and Cooper/Charlotte's drama that I don't care as much about. Then there's useless Pete. I actually liked most of this episode and the crossover because Addison is my favorite, particularly equal parts darker more fragile Addison and snarky great doctor Addison, but I don't care enough about Cooper/Charlotte/Violet/Pete to care about their stories on their own. They're just okay to me. They need to be linked to Addison somehow for me to care more and for the show to feel cohesive and right now they're not at all.


Post a comment

 optional
 optional
 
Find it fast

Zap2it on Facebook
twitter Zap2it Twitter Talk
Recent posts