It Happened Last Night

'Desperate Housewives': Was blind, but now I see

By Liz Pardue

   |  

December 7, 2008 8:13 PM ET

Felicityhuffman_desperatehousewivesWe're chugging right along toward a whole mess of revealing and resolving on Desperate Housewives, and while the plot may seem at times to be dragging inevitably toward the mystery's conclusion, I'm enjoying the twists, turns, and witty repartee we find along the way.

Lynette: First I must say this: If you need to be forced to sit down and eat fresh waffles, there's something seriously wrong with you. I'm looking at you, Scavo children. Unfortunately, family waffle time is interrupted when the police come to arrest Porter. Shouldn't the police have wondered how Dave knew it was Porter, and not Preston, in the club? At any rate, Mary Alice informs us that it will be many years before the Scavos will have breakfast together again.

With Bob as his lawyer, Porter admits to his parents that he has an embarrassing alibi: He was at Edie's. Tom: "What's wrong with girls your own age?! Do you know what I would give to sleep with a 17-year-old?" Ha! It turns out, though, that he was there to steal her gun and "scare" Mr. Schilling, not to sleep with her. So...worst alibi ever, basically. And it does beg the question: How did he know that Edie kept her gun in her dresser? Lynette does her crazy mother thing and returns the gun to Edie's house. She really takes this mama bear stuff to the extreme, doesn't she?

Bail is set at $20,000, which they would be able to scrape up if Lynette hadn't secretly given all their emergency money to Ann Schilling to get her out of town and keep her quiet. Bob acts horrified when she confesses this to him, but he had to know that they wouldn't be ideal clients after he heard Porter's "alibi," right? Lynette uses the restaurant as collateral for a bail bondsman, again secretly, which becomes a problem when Porter skips town after being threatened by Mr. Schilling, leaving Preston to take his place at the arraignment. Anyone else reminded of George Sr. and Oscar Bluth? No? Lynette, unwilling to lose the restaurant by admitting to the judge that Porter ran, allows Preston to take his place. Worse mom ever?

Bree: I am completely loving this plotline. More Andrew, please! Bree, upon finding out that Andrew and Alex (Orson's doctor) are an item, invites them both over to dinner. She awkwardly tries to express her approval, and invites Bob and Lee to enjoy in the awkwardness. Over Andrew's objections, Alex announces that they're getting married. Bree eagerly agrees to plan the wedding, without being asked. So clearly, the "Eagle State" isn't meant to represent California. 

Marciacross_desperatehousewives_s4_ There's just one fly in the ointment: Bob and Lee recognize Alex from an adult film. Bree: "By 'adult,' you mean complex and sophisticated?" No, not so much. And she chooses to break the news to Andrew in the most sensitive way possible: by presenting him with a copy of the movie in question. Turns out, he already knows -- Alex needed the money for med school, and made a mistake. Andrew's cool with it, since he doesn't want to be a hypocrite with his checkered past, and he loves Alex and all. Awww...way to teach Bree a valuable lesson about not being awful! It's actually really sweet, and he appreciates that Bree was willing to rent gay porn for him.

Susan: Katherine's tagging along with M.J. and Mike so that M.J. can get to know her as Mike's girlfriend, but M.J. freaks out on her, throwing ice cream in her hair and later dropping a bowling ball on her shoe. Apparently, Susan told M.J. in an attempt to comfort him right after Mike left that Mike may come back, so M.J. doesn't want Katherine getting in the way. And M.J. isn't the only one who believed it -- Susan feels like she needs closure, too. But Mike can't face the prospect of saying out loud that they'll never be together again, either. And if I sound bored writing this, it's because I was pretty bored watching it, too. Super predictable and clichéd. I'm assuming that they're trying to build sympathy for the three of them as a family in advance of Dave's actions. Otherwise, I don't get it.

Evalongoria_desperatehousewives_s4_ Gaby: Carlos can see!!! Shapes and shadows at first, but it improves rapidly. Unfortunately for Gaby, this means that Carlos is now able to discover all the stuff she sold to keep their family afloat during the past five years, including a family heirloom baseball signed by Lou Gehrig. He's upset, understandably. To get it back, Gaby has to dance on a table for the Italian businessman who bought it. While she's gone, Carlos realizes that she sold most of her designer clothes and shoes to make ends meet, too, and he feels like a big jerk. Yup. And so he buy a fancy new dress for her with the money that he got from re-selling the baseball. Aww! These guys seriously ARE the best couple on the show.

Dave: Brace yourselves, guys: It was the car wreck thing all along! Maybe! Dave is plagued by visions of a woman carrying a small blonde child, first asking them to go away while claiming he still loves them (Lynette overhears), then visiting them in the graveyard and telling them that he has a plan, so they need to wait a little longer before he can be with them. Mike, it seems, has to pay for taking them away from him, and Dave needs just the right moment. He wants Mike to lose what he lost. The graves reveal that he lost Lila Dash (loving wife and mother) and Paige Dash (loving daughter). Chilling!

So what, this whole brother in prison business was a red herring? Or is it more complicated than it seems right now? Because I gotta say, I'm not sure it counts as a surprise ending if you do what was obvious from the beginning after distracting us with a bunch of random filler about a band and your brother. 

So...car wreck? More than just the car wreck? Has Lynette gone off the deep end, or are her actions reasonable?

 
 
Zap2it Elite Sheet Must Reads from the Web's In-Crowd
 

i really do hope there's more to the mystery. i was hoping all season it wouldn't lead to the car wreck. so we have another mike involved mystery. LAME.

btw: what was the reason for dave going to prison? drugs? domestic (probably most logical one)? i'm looking back at dave's story about his brother. he said he was in prison with his brother when he was killed. what if it was dave who actually killed his brother "in self defense"? clearly mike would've recognized dave if they were all inmates. so that leaves out the mike killed steve in prison theory. i have my own theory that needs a little polishing though. i need more information on steve,

"they need to wait a little longer before he can be with them". so is dave planning to kill himself during his revenge?

I really liked the scene where Andrew told Bree how much he loved Alex. We've never seen Andrew really care about anyone else before, and I enjoyed seeing a new aspect of Andrew.

The Solis plot reminded me of the O. Henry story "The Gift of the Magi".

I hope there's more to the Dave story than just a husband seeking revenge after a tragic road accident. I'm hoping for more twists and turns.

Getting Preston to stand in for Porter is Lynette's worst idea ever. Wouldn't the police have taken Porter's fingerprints when he was arrested? She's an idiot for encouraging her son to commit perjury and I can't see how this could possibly work out well for the Schiavos.

Loved last nights episode, great one,love Gaby and Carlos, they are definitely my fav couple of the show. This season has been pretty stellar so far! Bravo!

Gaby and Carlos -- so sweet!

Sure, Lynette telling Preston to pretend to be Porter was not smart, but she's running in a panic. And, it's not like he's going to jail for Porter at this point. It was just an arraignment hearing; they had already posted bail and it's not likely that Preston would be taken back to jail after the hearing. Clearly, she would hope to find Porter before the actual trial.

I hope they move the Dave "mystery" along more quickly -- frankly, I find the need to have a "mystery of the season", and wish that that this particular plot device had not survived the 5-year-jump.

I liked the show but a few things were not right??

1st- So its ok for M.J. to see Susan dating and having her BF sleep over and teech him how to ride a bike and stuff, but not ok for his Dad who dosent live with him date? As a child of divorce, I was more upset when my mother dated then father.

2nd- How big is Fairfield (Or is it Fairview) anyway? Would Mike or Susan not have run into this family before or see the Father of the family they killed at some point during the whole thing? If I recall, In the opening scene when Mary Alice was talking she made a comment on how it was the same way they drove all the time and the city is not that big?

I also Lynette was not thinking straight when she decided to let him go in and lie for him. But its not like he was getting sent away to jail right then. There has to be a trail also. Just Daves word he was there is not enough to prove he did it.

Gabby and Carlos are the best couple on this show.

And they can still be in California. It is 5 years from now.

I don't understand why none of the housewivwes (excempt Edie throwing in her 2 cents to Dave) came over to see Lynette when her son was arrested for murder. Jeez they come over to discuss a hang nail all the other times but I guess your son being arrested is not important enough!

Katherine got what she deserved (or maybe what Mike deserved). You simply do NOT spring "Daddy's new girlfriend" on a small child at the start of a Daddy visit. But of course, most folks on DH are stupid.

Preston, Lynette, and Tom are all about to be guilty of being an accessory after the fact to Porter being a fugitive from justice. Maybe they will all have breakfast together again in prison!

I personally want to see Katherine and Mike end up together. I was never a huge fan of the Mike & Susan inevitability. Susan needs to be with someone who challenges her to grow up emotionally, and Mike was too much of an enabler for her silliness. Of course, good luck finding someone else who'll make her grow up. I don't know if Jackson is the one to do it.

I have faith that Dave's story is more than the car crash. It would be too lame otherwise to waste all this time on the most obvious reveal.

Now, Marc Cherry has set us all up to expect disappointment, and it should be a nice surprise when the mystery turns out to be something else entirely. Last minute misdirection. Like I said, I have faith!

Post a comment

Find it fast
Zap2it Twitter Talk
Recent posts