'How I Met Your Mother': The great burger search
Sometimes the small episodes of a sitcom are the best. It's the episodes where very little happens from which the most humor can be gleaned. Such was certainly the case with tonight's How I Met Your Mother, which revolved all around Marshall's search for the best hamburger ever created.
As you may recall, last season Marshall left his job at a soul-sucking corporation in order to pursue his dreams of becoming an environmental lawyer. That wasn't so much panning out for him, and by this week he had taken to sitting around in his underwear. And going out to get the mail in his underwear. And going out to restaurants in his underwear. The man needed help.
He wasn't too depressed to go to the bar with everyone else though, where the waitress informed them that they had just gotten a new chef who made the best burgers. Everyone -- save Robin, who was the hungriest and consequently not served -- tried their burger, and only Marshall found it lacking. It was not, he said, the best burger he'd ever had in the city.
We quickly flashbacked to Marshall's first days in New York City. He was, understandably a bit nervous. Okay, it wasn't understandable, as he was completely over-the-top nervous. It took Ted practically forcing the man out of the apartment for Marshall to dare venture into the city.
Once out, he loved the city I like to think of as home, he even found a hole-in-the-wall burger joint that served the best burger ever. I can't tell you how badly I wanted one. Of course, Ted wanted one too. Sadly, they couldn't find it again, and apparently Marshall and Lily tried every burger place in town, including the Corner Bistro. They tried to ask Regis (who, apparently eats at every burger place in the city too, including Marshall's mythical burger joint), but while Regis dreamed of the burger, he didn't know where to get it. Stupid guys, they never asked Robin about it. She knew exactly where the place was and they were off just as Robin's burger finally arrived. The hunt was on!
Unbelievably, ridiculously, not only was Robin correct about the look of the place (green door, small neon sign that said "Burger"), it was still there and it was open. Everyone, save Robin, was served, and everyone who was eating, save Marshall, thought it was the greatest burger ever created. One small meltdown later, Marshall stormed out and it was only then that the waitress confirmed that the restaurant they were in was modeled after a different one, one that was uptown (they were downtown). The hunt was back on!
One look at the block uptown confirmed for Marshall that they were, finally, in the right neighborhood. There was but one small glitch -- the place wasn't there anymore. Instead, there was an ATM for Goliath National Bank, a bank Barney's company had just bought and about which Barney had been singing the praises of all evening. Lily was rather perturbed with Goliath for sucking away her husband's possible merriment at having the most delicious burger ever created and noted to all who would listen (even if they didn't want to), that Goliath was an horrific bank.
It came as quite a shock to poor Lily when she learned that her Marshall had secretly taken a job at Goliath which Barney had first offered weeks earlier. Were there a burger to be had, it would have been Goliath's money with which Marshall could have fed his wife (not that she needs it as she has a job, but that's far less semi-poetic).
Actually, as it happened, the nice man from the XXX store right next door to the ATM informed the gang that the restaurant had just moved and for a mere hundred bucks he'd tell them its new location. Thank goodness for the FDIC insured Goliath National Bank and its conveniently located ATMs -- the hunt was on for a third time!
Finally at the new burger joint, Marshall confirmed that it was everything he ever wanted in a burger. At first Regis wasn't so sure, but eventually he did realize it was the burger he too had been searching for.
And all was right with the world (save the fact that I've had a burger hankering for weeks).
Quotes and questions:
- There were tons of funny quotes tonight, but I'm going to give you my personal favorite, Barney on the burger he had at MacLaren's -- "I love this burger so much I want to sew my ass shut."
- Here's what I really want to know, wouldn't it just have been faster to drive to Louis' Lunch in New Haven for the best burger?
- Seriously though, Regis. I thought the recurring Regis stuff funny at first, but kind of taken too far by the end. What do you think? Too much Regis, too little, or just right?
The TV and Film Guys Reviews -- Where we've wanted a good burger for so long.


The entire episode got old fast. I know the burger was symbolic of bigger things, but I just stopped caring, which is unfortunate because Marshall's my favorite character.
This is the second weak Marshall centric episode (along with last season's "Chain of Screaming"), and I really want him to get some good material soon.
I know that every episode cannot be about Ted and the "Mother", but when an episode strays from that main plot, it'd better be way better than tonight's.
Yeah, I found the entire episode rather boring. As for Regis: yuck! Who thought that was a good idea?! Another boring episode like this one, and I think I may strike this from my Monday nights.
wow! I dont know what you guys are smoking..I loved this episode and the reviews agree with me..This was a great episode!
I didnt think the season opener was that great but this episode totally made up for it!
a great one
Honestly, this show has been skating by. Last season and so far this one, I am more bored and have fewer outloud laughs. I kind of think of it like 2.5 Men...it has a formula, sticks to it very close and has a few episodes that stray. I think this one is close to off the Monday night live viewing and DVR schedule.
Terrible episode. This may have been about the best burger, but it couldn't even come close to Harold & Kumar. Even Barney's material was sub-par: Chinese = Indian = Mexican? Seriously?
Also, if 5 people order the same thing, it means nothing for Robin to get hers last. If one of my friends was starving, I'd let her have the first burger.
Yeah, someone should have given Robin a burger, or she should have just taken one of hers on the run. (Which reminds me, did they stiff all those subpar burger joints?)
The running Regis gag with the photos was funny, but we didn't need to hear from him more than once since he can't actually act. Would have sufficed just to see him quietly eating at the next table when they finally found the right place.
And am I the only one who thinks that in a show with no racial diversity it was a bit rude to have the only African-American character demand $100 for restaurant information? Ouch.
One funny moment that got lost in the shuffle was Robin eating bbq chips from a trash can and Ted yanking them away from her.
It's a television show. The brilliance of this show is that it attaches sentiment to ridiculous situations. It makes no pretense about trying to be an intellectual high brow program, or a political or social platform. This is a feel-good show, and quite honestly, it's one of the few shows that consistently hits that mark.
Find something else to complain about.
As a Notre Dame alum, it's a shame they couldn't have a Regis joke in there about the best burger being at CJ's in South Bend, IN.
Because that's where the best burger lives.
Josh: I found your line "nice man from the XXX store right next door" to be very funny.
I found this episode to be breezy and fun, if not destined to be a favorite.