It Happened Last Night

'Battlestar Galactica': Earth

By Andy Grieser

   |  

June 13, 2008 10:58 PM

Bsg Well, folks, we're at the "Battlestar Galactica" midseason finale, and boy does Korbi's look at the remaining episodes give me hope for what's to come.

Meanwhile, Starbuck and Apollo hope to walk together in the Temple of Aurora on Earth, at least as described by one of Caprica's philosophers. I wish I could peg Apollo's drawing to a real Earth structure, but it's fairly generic. Anyone want to step up?

On the basestar, Three lets Roslin's crew know they're hostages until the Final Four Cylons are handed over. The shenanigans continue, though: Roslin secretly tells Adama to blow the basestar and everyone aboard if the Final Four are handed over. Three and Adama head over to Galactica, where Three offers to trade the hostages for the Four. Looks like we have a standoff.

Tory, ever resourceful, says, she has to take Roslin's meds back with Three. The two go, and on the basestar Three introduces Tory to the other numbered Cylons. Tory embraces "her people" and refuses Roslin's request to mediate with Three. On the contrary, Three kills a hostage and says she'll kill more until the remaining Cylons are delivered. Well, damn.

Michaelhogan_battlestargalactica_24 Apollo and Adama plan a rescue mission, but music crackles into the heads of Tory, Tigh, Tyrol and Anders. The latter three convene around Starbuck's Destiny-viper, insisting something has changed. Well, that's an understatement. It had been crushed in a gravity well, after all. Tigh tells Anders to find Starbuck, and then goes to Adama.

What follows is one of the series' best scenes. In short, spitting phrases, Saul Tigh confesses his Cylonitude to lifelong friend Bill Adama. I have to think both men disbelieve at first, but Tigh grows more and more comfortable with his true identity, while Adama brings up many of the arguments (like that of Tigh's age) we viewers have been chewing over for months. It's heartwrenching to see Adama come to the truth.

Next up, Adama gets piss drunk! Apollo, meanwhile, takes command and has Tigh brought to an empty airlock. Three doesn't take kindly; at Tory's urging -- and damn, why does anyone listen to Tory? -- Three prepares to execute the hostages and arms the basestar's nukes. To his credit, Baltar tries to argue against this course of action. Tigh gives up Anders and Tyrol, but Three is set on her course.

...Until, that is, Starbuck turns on the Dradis in the Destiny-viper and catches a course heading that blends with the music-signal. Yep, the Final Four are broadcasting, or receiving, or something. Does this make Destiny-viper the last Cylon? Anyway, Starbuck stops Apollo from airlocking Tigh in the nick of time.

Remember when I said the scene above was one of the series' best? This is better. Three and her entourage meet with the Galactica crew (including the now-free Final Four) in the Destiny-viper's hangar. An Eight confirms the heading signal (435, not 325, to my dismay), but Three isn't quite ready to join forces and find Earth. "All of this has happened before..."

Jamiebamber_battlestargalactica_240 "...but it does not have to happen again," Apollo finishes. The human-Cylon war now has both races near extinction, he says, but actually working together for once could save them both on Earth. He's very presidential, and after a moment Three clasps his hand. I have to admit, I got chills.

Just one more jump, then, and... hey, they're at Earth! I actually expected the still-bad Cylons to show up and stop our heroes. But no, they're here, and everyone's happy. Seriously, Apollo even rips off his suit jacket and dances on top of the control table. What, no greetings from the planet? That missile defense system really doesn't work. Soon we find out why: Once on the planet's surface, an away team made up of the main characters finds not much more than radioactive mud and, in the distance, what appears to be the ruins of New York City. Um, oops. Can we at least blame it on the damn dirty apes?


71 Comments

Intriguing. I like the way they've kept turning the story in unexpected directions. The final half of the season should be a barnstormer. Shame it won't be till next year.


This was a great episode, capping off a good, but spotty, first half (seriously, why don't they just call this season 4, and the last 11 episodes season 5).

Today, we saw the growth of Lee Adama. The scene between Jamie Bamber and Edward James Olmos was great. Granted, I thought the whole Lee ripping off his jacket thing was, odd.

This show has a tendency to throw hints, and I am wondering D'Anna's early comment that only four of the final figve were in the fleet has any meaning. Does that mean the final five doesn't exist, and that it is a mythical god of some sort, perhaps the individual orchestrating this? Or does that mean the 5th cylon was among the prisoners on the baseship, whether it be Helo, Baltar, or maybe a lesser character, say, a Seelix?

All in all, this was the "ending". That is, the semi-happy ending. Comments from the cast, including the bit in Korbi's thing, haave suggested that the ending isn't exactly happy.


You know how they dont make a big thing out of the chief kid.......like hera, its cause the final cylons is....wiat for it!!!!!! not born yet.....its in 6's belly. that or Chief wife Cally is the final cylon, remember, she was killed before the Hub went down, she could still be somewhere


looks more like sydney from milsons point to me

http://flickr.com/photos/kurtmate_ezs/369847271/sizes/l/

i live on the other side


The last cylon is L. Ron Hubbard.


I loved Anders' droll comment to Tighe in the airlock, "Just a wild guess, but, did you tell them?"


The final cylon is **** Cheney. After all, they say only ****roaches can survive a nuclear war.

Seriously though, I like this turn of events. I was with you. I so used to politcal statements in scripted TV that I thought that they'd gt to Earth and all be blown out of the sky by some earliy warning system. My biggest worry is the drumming in "it all happened before" If they do a Star Trek "Voyage Home" time travel around the Sun to before the Cylon/Human War hit the Earth, I'll go postal.


I knew they wouldn't get to Earth in present times like they did on the original series(although it would have been funny if they showed up in the '70's like the original one). It was very cool to see them show up in the post apocalyptic future and now it will be interesting to see when the other Cylons show up or perhaps they already got there. Either way, best show this season. My only gripe is that they should have wasted less time earlier in the year and spread this last two episode over two hours instead of just one. The shock of Tigh revealing the truth to Adama could have made for a really good episode by itself. they could have had some flashbacks to the times they spent together in the fleet. I can't wait to see what happens in the final episodes.


Wow! I did have a Planet of the Apes flashback when they were standing among the wreckage of an abandoned city. Was looking around for the Statue of Liberty head at that point. I felt they were celebrating a little too prematurely onboard Galactica. Why not send a search party down before stipping and dancing on the table, Lee? Didn't anyone get concerned that no one one the surface tried to contact them? Great episode, great ending, waaaayyyy to long of a wait in store for us. Frack!


My thoughts are that in fact the final cylon wasn't with the fleet at that time bue was with the cylons.

Meaning it's either Bill Adama, Laura Roslyn, Baltar, Helo or Seelix.

My money is on Bill Adama. It just seems like the RDM gutt punch.


Post a comment

 optional
 optional
 
Find it fast

Zap2it on Facebook
twitter Zap2it Twitter Talk
Recent posts