Brooke runs dry on 'American Idol'

April 30, 07:22 PM

After a Tuesday show that saw the musical attributes of the American Idol Top Five overshadowed by Paula Abdul's perplexing and new-found ability to predict the future, which contestant would be heading home on Wednesday (April 30)? And why can't Paula just tell us the results in advance and save me an hour?

8:59 p.m. ET "You know more about these contestants than any other season," Ryan Seacrest says as part of his opening spiel, warning us that somebody will be heading home tonight. But is that really true? I know Jason Castro can't form a complete sentence, Syesha Mercado can cry like a baby, Brooke White can cry like a baby (but in a different way), David Archuleta wants to end world hunger and David Cook has high blood pressure. Is that really so much knowledge?

9:00 p.m. Kristy Lee Cook is in the audience, as pretty as ever. Somehow I don't miss her voice.

9:01 p.m. It appears that 45 million votes were cast last night.

9:02 p.m. The Group Sing is a Tribute to Neil Diamond, starting with "Cracklin' Rose." After several weeks of choreography-free songs, the producers have faced the limitations of what the show should be advertising as the Least Coordinated Top Five Ever. They're asked to, um, switch places on a platform and it looks awkward. The song progresses into "Song Sung Blue" and it's nearly unbearable. Brooke, Syesha and even David all sound dreadful. It's only when we transition to "Brother Love's Travelin' Salvation Show" and David Archuleta is every bit as joylessly cult-friendly as I could have hoped for that the Group Sing finds its spirit. Naturally, that's where it ends.

9:08 p.m. Gina Glocksen and Constantine Maroulis have been in the audience nearly every week, since they're hosting a Fox Reality series. For some reason we've decided that this is the week to draw attention to them and let them plug their product. Nobody asks Ace Young to plug anything. Poor Ace Young.

9:10 p.m. In our 2.5 minute salute to Tuesday's show, will we also give a nod to Paula's augury? I imagine her frantically sifting through the entrails of pigeons during commercial breaks. "Oh, Jason. The signs point to an ill omen in your second performance."

9:11 p.m. The clips of the mid-show judicial interlude skips Paula's prognostication. Ryan has been good about addressing most of this season's scandals that didn't relate to male stripping, so we still have nearly 45 minutes for him to bring it up.

9:12 p.m. Yup. Good Ol' Reliable Ryan. He vaguely addresses his doddering colleague by saying, "The rumors are not true. She's part of our family. And we love her." Wait. That addressed almost none of the rumors, unless you count TMZ's borderline libelous suggestion that just because one waiter said he served Paula a drink at lunch, she was probably drunk. It didn't even vaguely touch on whether Paula bases her absurdist comments on dress rehearsal performances. Nor did it hint at whether she reads the bumps on contestants' heads before each show to predict their upcoming success or failure.

9:13 p.m. We're already shunting contestants off to Cerberus' Chairs and the Saintly Sofa. Jason Castro is called out first. Clifford the Muppet admits that he didn't necessarily connect to either of his critically shredded Tuesday songs. But it meant nothing. He's safe for another week. And I'm already wondering if I can go watch the Red Sox and the Celtics and return in 45 minutes, save myself some annoyance.

9:14 p.m. Presumptive American Idol Finalist David Archuleta is up next. Without a single trip to the Bottom Three to date, surely Li'l' Archie is safe, right? He admits he could have looked like he was having more fun, but that didn't matter either. He's safe for another week. If I'm being honest, I'd have Archuleta pegged for a surprising trip to the Bottom Three this week, a shocker that would mobilize his fanbase and ease his inevitable run to glory.

9:21 p.m. Cat Deeley is just one of several reasons why it could be easily argued that So You Think You Can Dance! is like American Idol only better. That doesn't mean that I have to sit through an extended commercial for the summer series, not when I could check to see if the C's have remembered how to play basketball.

9:24 p.m. Out next is Presumptive American Idol Finalist David Cook. The Leader has lost a lot of weight in recent weeks. I wish to buy him a pizza, except for what that would do to his blood pressure. The men are all safe tonight, leaving Syesha and The Nanny facing nearly a half-hour of nervous tension.

9:26 p.m. Ryan reads the evaluations for both singers, making like he's actually going to give somebody the boot with 30 minutes to go in the episode. Then he sends them over to the couch under false pretenses, though Brooke earns a laugh with "We'll stay as long as we can."

9:32 p.m. This week's performing British import is Natasha Bedingfield, who I can't meaningfully distinguish from Sienna Miller except that one appears to sing and the other prefers to be caught topless at the beach by the paparazzi.

9:36 p.m. Well, I was liking this Natasha Bedingfield bird before she insisted on going over and giving Li'l' Archie a kiss on the cheek. It's not as creepy as Billy Crystal hitting on Hannah Montana at Idol Gives Back, but still...

9:37 p.m. I had hoped that last week's absence of viewer questions was a sign of things to come. I was wrong. Paula, sounding much clearer tonight, says that singing is hard and that's why she coddles contestants. The second question also goes to Paula, as tonight's goal appears to be showcasing her relative sanity. Some woman claiming to be Simon's first kiss gets the third question, causing him to snort into his Coca-Cola cup. Simon showcases a disarmingly human side by vividly remembering the woman in question. Can we please bring her to the finale?

9:46 p.m. You know what would be a great theme? Donovan Night. Isn't "Catch the Wind" already used in a different car commercial? That makes this week's Ford ad even duller.

9:47 p.m. Neil Diamond sings "Pretty Amazing Grace." The Celtics have a double-digit lead. Watching Diamond perform, I can feel the show's demographics aging up by the second. Goodness. And how old must his mother be? At least she wasn't the one who insisted he become a rabbi when he really wanted to head out to Los Angeles to become a jazz singer.

9:52 p.m. Is Simon joking when he says that he and Neil have a history? Did it involve kissing in the garden when Simon was 10?

9:56 p.m. It's finally time to eliminate somebody. And no, Ryan, the loser doesn't "literally" go home in 30 seconds.

9:57 p.m. Brooke knows she's done before Ryan says her name and she's already bawling.

9:58 p.m. I somehow don't think those kids are getting their nanny back.

9:59 p.m. Brooke thanks America, but tells them that this is going to be terrible for her. You made Brooke White cry, America! For that, you're going to go have a Time Out.

9:59 p.m. It's fitting that Brooke has to restart her exit song twice. It's become an Idol cliche that the departing singers are almost always better on their exit encores because the pressure's off and the emotion is high. This is really, really, really not the case with Brooke.

Thoughts on this week's results? You gonna miss Brooke?

And, as always, check out Zap2it's Guide to American Idol.

Comments

oh thank god! Please if you're a nanny there's a reason you haven't made it. Stick to children's songs. In fact, I see "saturday morning with Super Brook" in her future... or She a lil' Archie could have an ABC after-school special...

Kel | Apr 30, 2008 7:37:50 PM | #

I guess this means that neither Paula nor Simon can predict the future. I AM going to miss Brooke, but she was the obvious one to go at this point, as she was seeming to crack under the pressure. I'm glad Paula's prediction of Jason's future rolled off the voter's backs. Jason is still my fave, being the freshest new talent and staying true to himself.

Attila | Apr 30, 2008 8:00:24 PM | #

The black chick will be next followed by the lobotomized Castro dude. Guaranteed.

wam | Apr 30, 2008 8:17:31 PM | #

Natasha Bedengfield hugged David A because he said he would want to to a duet with her and l guess he was showing him love for saying that.

Ti | Apr 30, 2008 8:34:13 PM | #

Horrible title for the article. A poor attempt at wit ended up truly offensive.

kate | Apr 30, 2008 8:34:16 PM | #

It's sad that the youth of American have absolutely no taste in music as evidenced by the fact that Jason Castro wasn't sent home tonight. :-)

Okaloosajohn | Apr 30, 2008 8:45:44 PM | #

Gonna miss Brooke. She did have some good weeks and she brought a little emotion to the show.

Jason might make final 2...grrr...

Natasha Bedingfield was great. Neil Diamond was NOT.

Dandan, you make it sound like Archuleta's jailbait or something. Sometimes you make a big deal outta nothing. Listen to what Ti just said.

han | Apr 30, 2008 8:49:22 PM | #

Although I don't really think my original headline was inherently offensive -- It was a silly pun, mixed with a little slap about just how rarely American Idol sends its pretty white kids home ahead of foreigners or racial minorities -- I generally aim to stir up discussion, not randomly hurt feelings (unless I happen to dislike your contestant of choice).

Thus, I've changed the recap's headline in all of its dozen locations around the site.

Having taken care of that censoring, now back to discussion on tonight's elimination...

-Daniel

Daniel | Apr 30, 2008 9:09:37 PM | #

Well, I didn't see the original title, but given the web address of this page, I'd say it was probably hilarious!

Mike | Apr 30, 2008 9:30:26 PM | #

As bad as the performances were last night, they were nowhere near as bad as the three we saw tonight...

Mick | Apr 30, 2008 10:03:00 PM | #

Oh Daniel, I've been reading your blog all along, and your mancrush on Jason is so obvious. Why don't you just come out and admit it, instead of all of this "Clifford the Muppet" charade? Jason is the only contestant on this show who hasn't bent to the demands of shouting, maintaining a true singer/songwriter style. Plus, he's the only true amateur.

Magnetis | Apr 30, 2008 10:08:20 PM | #

I really like Brooke, but it seemed like the pressure of the show was REALLY getting to her, so I'm glad she was sent home, especially because Sayesha had such a good night. Sayesha has won me over in the last few weeks, and it's impressive that she has been in the bottom 3 so many times, but has dodged the bullet. Good for her!

My theory about Jason Castro's perplexing safety from the bottom 2 is that he's rallying the Texas A&M vote. Those Aggies look after their own!

Cat | Apr 30, 2008 10:12:10 PM | #

what was the original title?

monica | Apr 30, 2008 11:30:12 PM | #

Seacrest never said that Syesha and Brooke were the bottom two, just that one was safe and one was not. I know its not a reliable source, but DialIdol had Syesha on top last night. We already know that the judges (randy) don't like her and keep pushing her towards broadway, while ignoring Archie's mistakes. Could this be another way to try to subtly make America think Syesha was not doing well and actually save Castro/Archie or even Cook?

Bethany | May 1, 2008 12:09:20 AM | #

Seriously, WHY is Jason Castro still in this thing? Parents, for the love of God, take away your pre-teen daughters' phone priveleges!

Sean | May 1, 2008 12:36:33 AM | #

I agree with Bethany, something is a little fishy here. Not that I think DialIdol is realiable at any cost, but it did say Syesha recieved the most votes, so they just put Syesha next to Brooke for the hell of it. Unless it's like the top 2 or 3, I don't ever remember the highest person on DialIdol being at the bottom.

Anyway glad Syesha stayed, the most interesting scenario would be if Syesha/David C. were in the finale together.

Nina | May 1, 2008 12:47:40 AM | #

People who are voting for Jason Castro are utter and complete MORONS. It's sheer stupidity that is keeping him alive on Idol. The guy can't really sing. He's nothing more than some wandering minstrel on a cruise ship.

Come on you idiots! Between his dirty, stupid-looking dreadlocks, his pothead-ish strange facial expressions, and his "I don't really care" attitude, not to mention his stupid gold chain and cross........where is there any appeal to him? THE GUY SUCKS! Several weeks in a row of unbearably AWFUL performances. At least give the show some semblance of credibility by getting rid of this waste of space.

Jennifer | May 1, 2008 4:21:46 AM | #

What's the name of this show? Oh yea "American Popularity"!!

Litzy | May 1, 2008 4:59:51 AM | #

Granted I'm not voting for Jason Castro, but good grief people his looks have nothing to do with his singing. If he had "stupid-looking dreadlocks...pothead-ish strange facial expressions, and his 'I don't really care' attitude" and he could really sing you wouldn't care how he looked. To attack his looks is just plain bigoted, immature, stupid and rude!

D | May 1, 2008 5:01:40 AM | #

I hope the people who are so impassioned against certain contestants and who attack their being and those who do enjoy their music are voting for someone else. If they arent willing to at least back up their rude and hurtful statements by supporting those who they deem worthy over certain others, it is a hundred times more ridiculous and almost plain wrong.

My heart went out to Brooke. She seems so sweet and genuine. But my opinion is she should have been in the bottom along with Jason. Like someone said though, I'm not certain if Ryan said for sure that Syesha was in the bottom or if just Brooke was the lowest and everyone else was safe.
.......
The call from Simon's first kiss was hilarious! He almost blushed, it was great to see him a bit vulnerable.
.......
Rock next week. Interesting to see what they will choose, esp David A and Syesha. David C should be great but it is actually a of of pressure on him because people will already expect him to blow everyone away. If he doesn't it could be a problem.

Erin | May 1, 2008 5:44:08 AM | #

Dial Idol did have Syesha at the top and I found it strange that she was left with Brook to the end. they neve did say that this was the bottom 2.

I kinda think David A was the other bottom 2 and Idol did not want to say that because his "fans" would vote until there fingers fell of next week. I think they dont want him to win now. He has been a bore as of late. I think they are pushing David Cook now I think, with Syesha as runner up. Thats my feeling.

Kelly Clarkson | May 1, 2008 5:51:36 AM | #

I used to be amazed how they managed to stretch out an elimination show to half an hour. Let alone the hour we now have to endur. However, it does allow me to watch reruns of ... well anything... at the same time. I was shocked when Jason was safe first up. He really doesn't deserve to still be around. He hasn't grown, changed or improved the whole season. He admitted he didn't know any of the Diamond songs - I don't think he's known any of the songs he's sung except Over the Rainbow. I'm glad Syesha made it through because she's definately improved from dull and boring to entertaining with her new found broadway delivery. The Davids were safe as I thought they'd be but Archi needs a scare. There's something just a little too child star about him for my liking. Brooke has been losing it and even though I liked her second song last night it was time for her to go. Time for them all to go, actually. I think David Cook is the most well rounded and would be the most successful artist if he won. The other boys will be flashes in the pan. Syesha will make it on Broadway. Bring on the final - but please try to make it under 4 hours long.

Caz | May 1, 2008 6:00:44 AM | #

I CAN'T BELIEVE IT WASN'T CASTRO

True he's the only amateur but he's gotten worse over the weeks...MUCH WORSE.

Pookie | May 1, 2008 6:17:04 AM | #

I'm an occasional watcher (and not 14) but still don't get the PAIWDA love (maybe he was great earlier this year when I did not watch??). And what was up with the "Member's Only" jacket that he wore last night? I am sure it was some fantastic designer but I flashed back when I saw it. Every time I saw him, it was all I could focus on. Do they pick their own clothes and if so, what 16 year old would pick that?

Andy | May 1, 2008 6:28:17 AM | #

Completely agree with your post Caz. There is a way to criticize constructively without being rude or attacking in personal ways when we do not even know these people.

I esp agree with your assessment of their probable post-Idol careers. To me, David C has the most chance of achieving a long career of critical and popular success, like Kelly, Carrie, and Daughtry. Just the fact that he can arrange, write, and play as well as sing will also help. Syesha should have a great Broadway career- and I think she wouldnt mind that since she also loves acting. Jason and David A have loyal fans now but I'm not sure how lasting their success will be after the show. Will they sustain the interest of their current fanbases? I know some of all ages like them but I think where as more a variety of ages like David C, the other boys have a bit more of a younger female fanbase- and that age has a short attention span. Esp. If they don't do anything upbeat to compete with the spunk of the Mileys, Jonas bros, Taylor swifts and High school musical people. And look what happened to Taylor Hicks. Soul Patrol was definitely the flavor of the moment and soured the moment the show was over that season because he doesn't have the appeal to keep a variety of people interested longterm. Just my opinions.

Erin | May 1, 2008 6:35:21 AM | #

"I used to be amazed how they managed to stretch out an elimination show to half an hour. Let alone the hour we now have to endure."

It takes you that long to read the recap?

Chris | May 1, 2008 6:49:20 AM | #

Once these people hit top 7 or so, they all will have a shot to make a CD. The problem is: What kind of CD? Taylor Hicks, Bo Bice, Melinda Doolittle. There isn't a music format that supports the type of CD they'd make. Kellie Pickler, Bucky Covington, even Josh Gracin - they have a place to land and have some success.

What kind of record would Brooke White make? I can envision Kristy Lee Cook's CD - country. I can already hear David Cook's CD. I can even hear the kind of CD the Muppet would make. The Cooks, Castro, and even Carly have a musical place to land. Syesha could make a pop record.

Where does Archuleta land? He's a 17 year old nerd, with very little personality who happens to be a very good singer. He's mindful of Clay Aiken. Archie isn't funky enough to be a boy-band type act. He's not worldly enough to sing that type of music. I think now that he's closing in, the producers are wondering the same thing: If this kid wins, what kind of record would he make, and how the heck do we market him to pop radio? I bet they take the opportunity in Rock week to nail the kid.

Word Money G | May 1, 2008 7:08:09 AM | #

The muppet and the nanny should have been gone a looooong time ago.

Before Michael Johns.

They both are beneficiaries of that crappy Dial Idol that lets you redial, over and over again if you have a modem.

People should be allowed to have just one vote.

| May 1, 2008 7:10:43 AM | #

Natasha is Australian.

sasha | May 1, 2008 7:12:41 AM | #

Hey Magnetis, Jason Castro has been in a band, performed in clubs, and recorded his music. How does that make him more of a "true amateur" than any of the other contestants?

Beth | May 1, 2008 7:31:19 AM | #

I am at the point now that i can say i will not watch the show again until Castro goes home. Hopefully, if America has any sense at all, i will only have to miss one week. I have tried my best to get past the dreads and not look at the TV when he sings. His voice still pains me. It's time to move on. Plus, he can not give an intelligent interview!!!

Syesha has had the best vocals of any female on the show this year, but clearly the producers do not want it to be another female winner. I have said all along that David C. would win. The guys are far out-numbered when it comes to Idol winners, and they needed a male winner this year to help it balance.

All that being said, I was sad to see Brooke go this week when it should have been Jason.

Marie | May 1, 2008 7:39:00 AM | #

Well I'm not a tweeny, I'm 63 (gasp, did I type that outloud?).

I really liked Brooke and would have prefered Syesha to leave, although Brooke was shaking a lot these past few weeks. I like all the "boys", I think Syesha is extremely beautiful and thought David A. would win from the get-go. However David C. has grown on me. I like a grin. And Jason ....certainly can't sing as well as the others, but he sure is purrty...I know he needs to go but his softness is appealing.

I do think this is the best year of Idol since the second. Look-wise and talent-wise. This is a really good looking group.

And David A. Win, lose or draw, Disney should snap him up.

SUSIE | May 1, 2008 7:58:49 AM | #

Seriously, what was the original headline?

jessie | May 1, 2008 8:02:09 AM | #

Shame, shame on blogger Jennifer. Just because you don't like someone's singing style is no reason to call everyone who does a moron. Also, to stoop so low to start mocking his faith. That is the sign of a true bigot. I don't particularly like David Cook's style of singing, with all the shouting, etc., but everyone is entitled to their taste. I'm not going to mock whatever faith he is and call his fans morons. Shame on you.

Magnetis | May 1, 2008 8:18:35 AM | #

Response to Beth: Jason was in a band as a DRUMMER. He only sang about five times at a bar before going on Idol. He didn't sing when he was on the Cheyenne show--he played her supposed love interest. His recordings are all self-recorded--no record company has recorded him. He is the only true amateur.

Magnetis | May 1, 2008 8:23:12 AM | #

Magenetis, if you get paid to do something, you are no longer an amateur, no matter whether it's once or a thousand times.

Beth | May 1, 2008 8:28:55 AM | #

P.S. I think the whole "amateur" issue is overblown anyway. If Justin Timberlake ever shows up as a contestant, then we'll talk. But just because someone has already been trying to break into the business shouldn't disqualify them IMO. AI is showcasing unknown talent. Say what you will about contestants with previous "experience", to the majority they were all unknowns.

Beth | May 1, 2008 8:33:54 AM | #

The original title was "White Power fails to deliver" or somesuch. I noticed that some people might take offense at it, but I didn't.

Brooke was the right choice to send home. Clifford and Li'l Archie need to go next, in that order. In my perfect world, the Final Two would be Cookie and Syesha. That's not going to happen, but I can dream, can't I?

Siansonea | May 1, 2008 8:38:40 AM | #

I felt bad for Brooke but at least she left after what was decent night, her second song was pretty good. Jason continues to survive, perhaps he supplies Paula?

The funniest moment of the night was when Beddingfield said she wanted to say "hi to David", she started to walk to the couch and David Cook stood up, only to have her cuddle with archie. I think Mr. Cook thought the hot blonde wanted to rock. embarrassing!

Ford commercial sucked.

jbw | May 1, 2008 8:54:09 AM | #

Back to Beth: I agree totally, and the point is that Jason has never been paid to sing before, nor has he been showcased on TV before as a singer. David Cook has been a professional for quite a while, and it shows. I guess that's one of the reasons I'm so fond of Jason--this is all new to him and he doesn't have that smugness of the professionals. This exposure on Idol is good for everyone, though.

Magnetis | May 1, 2008 8:58:20 AM | #

Got to agree with Magnetis on this one re: Castro's status as amateur vs others. He hasn't been a front man, had a contract, released a CD, toured, etc. Seem pretty straight forward.

He seems a bit overwhelmed by it all, like he stumbled onto stage and wondered how he got there. Some think it's a sign of not caring, but the feeling that he alone wouldn't sell his soul for a record deal is probably endearing him to some viewers.

Just a thought...

PM | May 1, 2008 9:03:37 AM | #

Why are people hating on Jason Castro?!? The guy is maybe the only unique talent out there this season. Vocally, there is NOTHING unique about David Cook. Even some of his arrangements were stolen from better artists. He's going to end up making terrible music along the lines of Daughtry/Nickelback/etc...

Jason is the only contestant they've had this year who's album I would be interested in checking out. I think we all know there is nowhere for David A to go in the industry. I see a Clay Aikens-like trainwreck coming...

Kermit | May 1, 2008 9:05:01 AM | #

Brooke shoul have been voted off last week, and carly should still be in the running

susan | May 1, 2008 9:09:44 AM | #

Daniel, you crack me up!

"You made Brooke White cry, America! For that, you're going to go have a Time Out."

That is priceless. Thank you for making me laugh out loud, seriously.

Thank goodness vote for the worst didn't succeed with keeping her in the game.

Terry | May 1, 2008 9:49:47 AM | #

re: bashing - At this point everyone left can hold a tune. So it's down to personal preference and there are no "right" or "wrong" choices in who we like. It would be like me telling someone they are stupid and wrong for liking Pepsi vs. Coke - it's their taste!

The discussion on who is really marketable in the long run is a good one (a lot more interesting than the bashing). Castro probably has a very good shot right now of finding a market. Being a niche singer is detrimental in the show but advantageous in the real world. It's much more risky to be kind of good at many genres but not great at any one of them.

PM | May 1, 2008 9:53:21 AM | #

I also don't get the Jason love. Bad vocals is not "unique", it's just bad. And every time I see someone post that they like him cuz he's pretty or purty or whatever, it just makes it even more obvious that this is a popularity contest and not a singing contest. Sad people.

Lisa | May 1, 2008 10:02:57 AM | #

In regards to Cook..."He's going to end up making terrible music along the lines of Daughtry/Nickelback/etc..."

Man if you are a rock artist, to be as successful as Nickelback would be a dream come true. People need to look at reality instead of judging by the music they like. David Cook is the only one left that has sung any song that would get serious radio play. In the music industry, that is success. The others have a good voice, heck they all did to have to make the top 12, but you have to be able to be a hit and be popular. Guys like Castro have talent but he'll never have a top 50 album because of his niche market.

Josh | May 1, 2008 10:09:19 AM | #

As one of the other posters mentioned above, they were careful to not say that those 2 were in the bottom 2. Dial Idol had Syesha in 1st followed by David Cook then David A. then Castro with Brooke in last. I like that they didn't (necessarily) put the 2nd lowest vote getter in the final 2. Of course this is assuming that Dial Idol is relatively accurate.

Rishi | May 1, 2008 10:10:35 AM | #

Idol got it wrong again. Of the 4 that are left,only David Cook will sell any CD's.
David A is the most boring singer I have ever heard. The other 2 stink. Brooke will sell more CD's then the winner. Just like Chris Daughtry out sold the winner of season 5. I can't even remember the name of the winner that year. Only 2 winners have ever made it big. Carrie Underwood and Kelly Clarkson.

nwb | May 1, 2008 10:15:48 AM | #

Jason will do very well...On a Cruise Ship as the 3rd act.

Just Bob | May 1, 2008 10:30:12 AM | #

I think having Syesha next to Brooke and having Jason revealed safe first (to sort of give impression that he was safe next week) was another desperate attempt by the producers to try to get rid of Jason before the finale.

Everyone knows when someone is in the bottom two their fans rally the next week to save them. So this is the newest in their atttempts to get rid of Jason. It's obvious from Paula's producer written comments and Simon's extra harsh critique that he was the target this week but they had to change it because Paula messed up and couldn't even do the simple job of reading the producers notes.

I figured out her perfect replacement. Britney Spears. Hiring Brit would keep the formula of a cruel judge and a wacky side kick for him to kick.

It would also help revive Britney's near dead career, prove her sanity( hey she couldn't do worse then Abdul), give her a big payday for minimal work and a constant platform to promote her albums. SHe could tour in the summer and fall.

This solution would revive Idol's sagging ratings and most importantly send Abdul back to obscurity.

Jason S. | May 1, 2008 10:34:34 AM | #

Hey Daniel is your new title making reference to Brook's libido? :)

Jason S. | May 1, 2008 10:35:58 AM | #

Josh, you said Castro's niche will hold him back from mainstream success. It's true that he'll never rock out a stadium or sit in the #1 Billboard spot, but I'm not convinced that he couldn't have enough success to make a solid career out of music for a while. Think along the lines of Jack Johnson. Maybe...?

Cook is ready to go and sell tons of records.

PM | May 1, 2008 10:39:07 AM | #

Uhhh. Nickelback is awful. I don't care how many records they sell. They are absolutely awful. And their success only proves the bad taste of America.

The only thing worse then America's taste in music is their taste in leaders. America's stupidity was proven when they re-elected a President who was a complete failure that led his country into an unwinnable war to further his family's oil interests.

Jason S. | May 1, 2008 10:42:42 AM | #

To Lisa: "Bad vocals" is all relative. It's all a matter of taste. Some people prefer soft lilting melodies, while others prefer shouting and bellowing, like David Cook. I'll be the first to say I don't like David Cook's style, but that certainly doesn't mean I think he's a bad vocalist. Cook has the whole package as far as smugness, shouting, theatrics, etc. Lots of people like that. I think he'll do well. Jason has the whole package as far as humble demeanor, soft lilting melodies and vulnerability. I also think Jason will do well. Different strokes for different folks.

Magnetis | May 1, 2008 10:46:55 AM | #

Jason S. - curious, do you actually like any of the top 10 singers?

Magnetis - you nailed it.

PM | May 1, 2008 10:53:44 AM | #

There really is some great discussion going on here today. I know I've said stuff already but I have some more thoughts on the marketability of the final 4.
......
I do have a favorite Idol of this season, but I love all types of music and am very capable of being fair in critiques and capable of liking more than just one contestant:)
......
Syesha is beautiful and a good singer but I don't see anything in her voice or her personality that will help her stand out and sell a significant amount of r&b/pop albums. Again, Broadway really should bring her the most success leading into more acting later. David A could possibly sell a lot of albums through pop or Disney/pop but I still think it will be more on the difficult side to market and sell him. He doesn't grab you with his personality. And yes Clay and Josh Groban have success with the adult contemporary genre but they are adults. David is 17 and just seems too young to sing and act so old. And Clay and Josh Groban's voices are better than Davids. I just don't know how far they can take this kid but he does have a nice voice and seems like a good guy. Now, Jason is the most unique and that really can work to his great advantage out in the music world. I apprecaite a laidback personality too. I do think his range a little too thin and he needs to try a bit harder. I really think he never expected to go this far and is a little overwhelmed. He is probably most comfortable playing drums and is just finding how to be a singer in front of the whole country. I appreciate his sound when he really nails some of these songs and do think he could find good success as someone that is unique and has great potential but he needs to get a little more at ease in front of people and work on his vocal skills. Overall, I think He could either surprise us all and have a very respectable career after the show or fizzle out for all of the positives and negatives mentioned above. David C still has the most possibility of selling the most records. I think that Jason is the most unique but David C is the most well rounded as a singer and musician and could appeal to the most variety of listeners. And yes, he has taken some others artists' arrangements, but hello, most of the Idols do that the entire show. He had made more completely original arrangements than any past Idol I can recall, and I really appreciate that. I think he has the best stage presence of those left too. Now everyone here won't agree that he is the best but I think the argument that he has the potential to sell the most records is valid:)
.......
One last note, I don't really care that some have more prior experience than others. I'm not going to buy someone's album based on number of years experience, I buy it if it is good music. And I seriously think every season of idol to come will have singers that attempted to make it in music already. Whats wrong with that? To me that just shows that they love it. Its about undiscovered, unknown (to the average American) talent not complete amateur talent. You won't find manu good singers that are complete amateurs anyway.

Erin | May 1, 2008 10:54:35 AM | #

Jason Castro is a really good singer.

Yes sometimes he struggles with the theme nights (which have been ridiculoudly bad this year) but so has everyone else besides David Cook.

Cook is definitely a better singer but Jason has something that is harder to come by. He seems honest and his voice is pure.

It's like comparing Gwen Stefani to Christina AGuilera. Christina has a much better voice. But Gwen has a star quality and presence that makes her more believable and more likable then Aguilera.

I do believe Cook should win though because he has been more consistent and the two stand out moments of this season were Billy Jean and Little Sparrow.

But the finale should be Cook and Castro.

Jason S. | May 1, 2008 10:56:02 AM | #

PM --- This is the first year that I have really liked American Idol because there are a lot of good singers.

I really like Cook, Castro, Carly, Brooke.

I also thought Chickezie, Michael Johns, and Kristy Lee had a lot of talent.

David A, Ramiele, are completely boring.

Syesha Is ok.

I generally listen to rock and alternative music. I am a huge Jane's Addiction, Pearl Jam, No Doubt, fan.

I can also listen to Pink, Madonna, or Kelly Clarkson on occasion.

Jason S. | May 1, 2008 11:01:25 AM | #

Jason S you are full of surprises. I thought you were going to say they all suck! Good commentary.

Erin I hope people take the time to read your post because although it's long it's insightful.

PM | May 1, 2008 11:08:28 AM | #

One thing on David A. I have held back on saying anything about him even though I agree with a lot of what people are saying because he is so young. He seems younger than an average 17 year old. This may be because this kid's entire life experience has been mom and dad throwing him on any stage they could find like a performing monkey. When he hits 18 and can venture out on his own and live a little, I wonder how that will impact his performance ability. I think the jury's out on him.

PM | May 1, 2008 11:13:21 AM | #

What I really could not stand was David A's expression of shock that he was safe. Really, David? This just looked like a cheap effort to garner even more support for all the stress he is going through. C'mon!

Donnie | May 1, 2008 11:13:28 AM | #

Jason S- I tgnk you have some great points- but do we really want to get into politics too? I don't think we could all handle that and Idol :P But again, just because you think artists like Nickelback are terrible, other people love it. We all like what we like and to say someone else is wrong for liking what we dont like seems very unfair. As with lumping Americans in one category!
......
And Josh is right. As long as the artist is happy with his/her own music the are making, I think they would love to have the success of Nickelback. Also agree with Josh that David C will be played on the most mainstream stations but like PM said, Jason could possibly have a career like Jack Johnson.
.......
Magnetis- I got a kick out of how you try to sound subjective about vocals but it is obvious by the adjectives used that you think Jason has more quality than David! :) And that's perfectly fine, it just made me laugh.

Erin | May 1, 2008 11:15:21 AM | #

Wow! Brooke made Ramielle look like the picture of composure upon hearing the bad news. And even Ramielle pulled it together enough to sing decently on her exit song.

But that's OK, Brooke. You were likeable and distinctive, even if you were not the best singer. And heck, when others were eliminated, Brooke usually cried more than them, too. I guess she is coming soon to a coffeehouse near you.

Tony | May 1, 2008 11:19:23 AM | #

PM- haha I know, I always have a lot of things to say. At least a few are willing to read my posts! I agree totally with the comments about David A

Jason S- wow your post surprised me too. I was hoping you liked something about the Idols this season but wasn't sure at times :) I really enjoy reading your posts as well as many others on here.

Erin | May 1, 2008 11:24:13 AM | #

It was kind of hard to get/be excited last night when Brooke was so sad and crying after being eliminated, but I am. She was over-due to leave (definately should have last week instead of Carly and then Jason this week... Carly should be in the top 4). And per true Brooke fashion, she goofed up at the start of her farewell encore song last night (though this time it was understandable why).

As Carly is gone now, that leaves David COOK as the most well rounded and deserving contestant left... he should win, but I'd rather he take 2nd. Let Archuleta win and be the one to get his debut CD content and his life controlled for the next year or so by "Idol" producers instead.

Steve | May 1, 2008 11:24:25 AM | #

Erin, lol, yes my adjectives were a bit pejorative for Cook, I agree. But I do understand why people like him.

PM: Interesting perspective on Archie. I hope he doesn't turn out like another Michael Jackson. Not success-wise, but personal life-wise.

Magnetis | May 1, 2008 11:28:33 AM | #

I will miss Brooke...she was a breath of fresh air with her always smiling attitude....Plus she's a knock-out...!! But I think Jason should have been deployed weeks ago, not Carly & Brooke..!!!

PAUL | May 1, 2008 11:35:25 AM | #

What the f* is going on being down on David Archuleta. I find it rather disgusting that the pot shots on here in unfounded especially the person who writes this blog. David A has just been consistent, that's all, what's wrong with that. Boring, y'all need to check yourself. It's saddens me that those who take pot shots at some of these contestants can do so knowing that they can't defend themselves. As for the shock look, I am sure David A and probably others were given the stats of DialIdol etc and were probably shocked to know they were safe...and it's now wonder why they say this country is going to pot...it's pure hate that I've been reading here....it would be rather nice if y'all just say, "Ok I don't like David A to win, I prefer David C" and leave it at that but just the mean spirited comments just leaves me sick....I also will miss Brooke, she's one classy lady!!!

aiken4olivia | May 1, 2008 11:50:50 AM | #

Erin - Sorry about bringing politics into it. I was just in a weird mood. Also sorry about Putting down Nickelback. I forget a lot of people love them. I just get frustrated by which artista are successful when I see Nickelback and Creed sort of stealing Pearl jam/s sound from 1992 and becoming hugely succesful at it while Pearl Jam is evolving and constantly changing and reinventing themselves and their album sell a tenth of what Nickelback does. Guess I'm just bitter but hey I can admit it.

Jason S. | May 1, 2008 11:53:14 AM | #

Jason S - really no need to apologize, I was just commenting:) I do think it could get ugly fast on here in a political debate- it gets ugly enough with American Idol talk unfortunately.

Hey I think Pearl Jam is better than Nickelback and Creed too. Don't worry about Pearl Jam though, they have done plenty well for themselves and have a great career.

Erin | May 1, 2008 12:09:19 PM | #

Can we please bring back Danny Noriega?

Boy do I miss his attitude and of course his voice. He's certainly more entertaining than David A. will ever be and more talented than Jason ever was.

I do think it will be a battle of the "Davids" at the end. Just think of all the great marketing Fox can generate from that.

"David VS David"
"The Battle of the Davids"
"From A to C"
"Cookie and Lil' Archie"
"DTV" (David T.V., I know kind a weak)

And you can just picture Ryan saying at the end of the finale; "...and the winner is (long pause) David (another long pause)... we'll be right back after this commercial break" (Ford/Apple/Tylenol PM/Fox shows promos/More Fox shows promos/So you Think You Can Dance extended promo/Ford again) "...David...Cook"

Later.

Junior Mints | May 1, 2008 12:20:16 PM | #

How convenient for Daniel Feinberg to erase those posts criticsing his racism, then delete the offending phrase and pretend it never happened. That he is the epitome of tolerance and equality. The truth is he thinks past (and present) racial injustices are fodder for jokes. That right there is racism. Somehow, he never uses the holocaust in his jokes. Why not? Why are blacks the only people you bash? Who's editing this site, anyway?

Dernell | May 1, 2008 12:23:54 PM | #

Darnell get over yourself..It was a play on words THATS IT! They do it every week, all of them do. Get over it. It was not offensive. Like he said, It was a silly pun, mixed with a little slap to it.

Just Bob | May 1, 2008 12:33:56 PM | #

Dernell - What was the original title? I didn't read it.

Jason S. | May 1, 2008 12:35:50 PM | #

The original title was "White Power Falls Short" - type "presumptive american idol finalist" into Google and it's the second result. (Plus, look at this page's web address for further confirmation.

Joe Googler | May 1, 2008 12:51:38 PM | #

Did anyone see Brooke on the Fox news morning show? Carly Simon talked to her on the phone and gave her a great compliment.

Trupen | May 1, 2008 12:57:40 PM | #

Congratulations to the David's, Syesha and Jason for making American Idol's top 4 for season 7. May they all have decent careers, wherever it may be.

lem | May 1, 2008 1:05:05 PM | #

I am literally in a state of yummy goodness. No more Brooke. No more Brooke! Sigh. I really don't care what happens now. I mean, Clifford the Muppet Castro could win the whole thing and I'd probably buy his CD. No more Brooke 4-eva! Well, until the finale.

Girley | May 1, 2008 1:29:37 PM | #

Dernell,

Not a single post was erased. The title of the post was changed and I posted explaining that change. That doesn't count as not acknowledging. In fact, that counts as acknowledging. The previous title was "White Power Falls Short on 'American Idol.'" I explained the point I was making.

As for your contention that blacks are the only people I bash... Well, that's just hilarious.

Thanks for reading.

-Daniel

Daniel | May 1, 2008 1:33:00 PM | #

I am glad that Brook is gone, nothing special about her. She wants to be a famous so bad, but doesn't have outstanding quality to present. I think she is better to be a nanny working for a wealthy couple.

Nick | May 1, 2008 1:34:21 PM | #

Nick | May 1, 2008 1:34:30 PM | #

That's right, Dernell: If you've been reading Daniel's posts, you'll see plenty of Jason-bashing, under the nickname "Clifford the Muppet." It's all in good fun though, as we all know that Daniel has a secret man-crush on Jason. We always tease the ones we love, you know.

Magnetis | May 1, 2008 1:38:14 PM | #

Brooke and Jason should have been gone right after Ramiele (sp?).

They are a 2 headed Sanjia!

| May 1, 2008 3:26:08 PM | #

If this show finishes up the season based on VOCAL TALENT, then Syeshia and David A. better be in the Finals. Unfortunately David C. will be and Syeshia will probably go next week. It's sad that this show is all about popularity...

I was sad to see Brooke leave but she was starting to stagger. I really think Syeshia is the best singer left. I think she always gets a bad rap but she sings better than any contestant left....maybe except for David A. All David Cook does is the same soft, low rocker voice to EVERY song and all Jason does is his quiet voice to EVERY song.

Scott | May 1, 2008 4:29:18 PM | #

Hello to all and I love most of the comments and thoughts except for the guy who is starting in on non-existent racism
My take is David C SHOULD win this thing by a wide margin, but in the world of Idol, where better contestants are almost always eliminated early, anything is possible. The only positive I see if Cook doesn't win is more freedom to do his kind of record like Daughtry.
Why Castro is still here is a mystery, but then again the public crowned Ruben and Fantasia.

Dr Kennedy | May 1, 2008 4:30:00 PM | #

Hey Scott, to be fair, isn't part of celebrity being likable? Call it whatever you want - popularity, the "x factor", charisma - but there is usually something there that draws people in.

To borrow from something Simon said a few times during the audition rounds, I'm not sure Syesha is as good as she thinks she is. Confidence is a very attractive quality. Arrogance is not. I have instinctively felt put off by her demeanor, and maybe I'm not alone in that feeling.

PM | May 1, 2008 5:15:45 PM | #

Daniel, I thought your original title was hilarious! Too bad you changed it. I totally expected Syesha to be gone, even though I thought she didn't deserve it. Simon and Randy both tried to get her ousted because they are worried she might actually make the final 2 (they probably looked at Dial-Idol). I love it! Unfortunately, David A. is still going to win. Can't fight the teen girls.

walt | May 1, 2008 5:32:49 PM | #

Scott- Yes the show often resorts to popularity over musical ability. Its only a bad thing if a person's popularity is extremely disproportional to the amount of talent they possess. The most successful artist will be a good combo of both- very talented and very popular. If they arent appealing they wont sell.

And I have to say I think David Cook's voice has been anything but soft and low on many songs. And his vocals from Daytripper to Billie Jean to Little Sparrow to Music of the Night have been quite varied.....where as David A's voice, while good, sounds EXACTLY the same regardless of song choice/style.

MSH | May 1, 2008 5:37:17 PM | #

well put, MSH

PM | May 1, 2008 5:44:03 PM | #

Walt - About the preteen/teen girl vote, I'd say don't discount that when it comes to Syesha either. Being the only girl left in the competition, Syesha could benefit from a "girl power" kind of vote from kids who want to see a female in the finale.

PM | May 1, 2008 5:46:28 PM | #

That's an interesting thought about the "girl power" vote, PM. I read zap2it's exit interview with Brooke, who said this is definitely the boy's year, if based on nothing else but the fan mail they get. She said the boys would get bags and bags of mail every day, while the girls would get maybe three each. I dunno--I think girl crushes are stronger than girl power. Plus, Syesha just doesn't exude the type of warmth that Brooke did. I would wager that Brooke's votes are now going to Archie.

Magnetis | May 1, 2008 6:02:57 PM | #

Paula proved on Tuesday that you should not mix Percocet and alcohol. She should be fired for letting the cat out of the bag. The cat being that the show is fixed. She should be under a doctor's care, not under studio lights. What a mess!

Paris | May 1, 2008 8:25:11 PM | #

Leave Paula alone. The gov't regulates game shows. Check out some history (the show of shows). They can't get by with rigging the results of a televised game show.
Of course it's not just based on vocal ability. It isn't called American Singer. It is what we idolize here in the good ole USA, and being able to sing is only one factor in the whole equation. Let's have some fun and stop readng more into this than it is: I don't think it's a biased blogger or a juiced-up judges or pre-chosen champions. It's a game folks. A game. Enjoy. Let the hopeful contestants enjoy and not read your hurtful, biting, unrealistic, uninformed comments. You don't think of them as people, but they are just like you. No wonder the pressure was getting to Brooke. I'm sure she read some of the innane remarks being made on sites like this one. Peace out.

Mr Right | May 2, 2008 1:38:26 PM | #

Here's what I fear-- the 2 David's fan base will mobilize and get rid of one of the David's next week (remember Tamyra Grey) Then Syesha or Jason will go after that which means one of the Davids will be against Sye or Jason in the final 2, thus assuring a David win. One of the two David's should win IMO, but it should be in a head-to-head battle.

John | May 3, 2008 4:15:08 PM | #