It Happened Last Night

'Brothers & Sisters,' minus one

By Sarah Jersild

   |  

April 27, 2008 9:38 PM ET

Emilyvancamp2_brothersandsisters_s2 Is it physically impossible for Walkers and quasi-Walkers to be happy for more than 10 minutes at a time on Brothers & Sisters? Apparently, if this episode full of DNA tests, political machinations, business skullduggery and just general Walker angst is anything to go by. Heck, even the panacea of ice cream gave people headaches. Walkers just can't win!

I need a drink -- this spoilers thing is such a downer.

Rebecca gets the results of the DNA test (via the phone, and not in person with Justin at her side), and discovers she's David's daughter. Dammit! As Holly has just left the house, Rebecca directs her ire at David, who is not surprised by the result but a bit surprised by the rage. Buh... your mom was trying to give you a good life! I was a coked-out mess and would have been a horrible father! He promises to make things right, but instead confirms his no-goodnik status by lying to Holly that he's got a job in New York, bailing on a romantic weekend, and saying that he just pursued her out of "nostalgia."

Rebecca decides she loves being a Walker, and what do Walkers do (besides talk about each other)? They lie! She tells Justin the DNA test came up Walker, so she's still his little sis. Justin isn't sure he's happy about this, because he's evidently having naughty feelings directed at his "sister," but he doesn't say anything. Instead, he sublimates those dirty thoughts by teaching Rebecca to surf. Just a hint, Justin: if you're trying to convince yourself you're not madly attracted to a girl, perhaps you should pick an activity that does not involve close contact and bikinis, hmmm?

Taylor asks Robert to be his VP, but only after being the most obnoxious schmuck on the face of the planet. Kitty is reluctant to go through all that campaigning again, especially for the benefit of someone like Taylor, and she tells Robert he should turn down the offer. She needs some time with Robert for herself! And hey, how I am supposed to get knocked up if you're out campaigning all the time? Robert opines that she knew about his ambition from the start, and he really wants this, but in the end, Taylor is such a objectionable schmuck that he turns the offer down. Taylor warns Kitty that Robert will resent her forever. Shut it, Taylor.

Sarah is shocked to find out that the China deal went through despite her telling Saul not to do it. She feels horribly betrayed: How could you abuse my trust? Saul shares my feelings and is having none of it, because hey, she was acting like a spoiled brat with the whole "we can't do the deal but I want to keep my boyfriend -- you do it!" stunt she pulled last week. She asks Graham if he knew about the end-run Saul pulled, and Graham in insulted. Later, Nora tells Sarah to lighten up and trust people. So she makes a big apology, and then finds out she was right all along -- the Chinese company is declaring bankruptcy, but Ojai Foods is still on the hook for the ancillary deals and will be hemorrhaging money. Great -- now Sarah's going to be completely insufferable. Um, more insufferable.

Scotty cuts his hand at work and reveals he doesn't have health insurance, which, after some consultation with his brothers, prompts Kevin to propose a domestic partnership arrangement. That's not the sort of proposal Scotty had in mind -- when he gets hitched, he wants it to be for keeps, not for convenience. I really wish I cared more.

In other news, Nora threatens to redecorate the house to mend her broken heart, then realizes (1) the house looks pretty sweet as it is, and (2) she really wants to give families of pediatric cancer patients a place to stay. Also, Tommy continues to be nearly superfluous. What the heck did Balthazar Getty do to piss off the writers?

Highlights, thoughts and odds and ends:

  • I didn't think anything would be worse the a romance plotline between Rebecca and Justin. I was wrong: The thwarted, needlessly complicated, undoubtedly drawn-out romance between Justin and Rebecca sounds even worse.
  • Fantastic job by Emily VanCamp on Rebecca's meltdown to David when she got the DNA results. That was great work. Patricia Wettig's turn when Holly was being inexplicably dumped by David was pretty spiffy as well.
  • I'm slightly confused as to how David translated "I'm going to make this ok" into "I'm going to bugger off without explanation."
  • On a shallow note, I loved Rebecca's formal dress. She looked stunning.
  • Poor Kitty -- after contemplating the futures of her potential embryos (or blastocysts, as Tommy somewhat creepily informs us), she discovers  that none of them are viable.
  • I kind of loved the Walker kids talking about how Nora deals with family trauma by redecorating the house. Rebecca's take on that was great -- "If she finds out I'm not a Walker, she'll put a third floor on the house."
  • I've always despised Taylor, but the marching in when he showed up early and Kitty was in a towel was just too much. Dude, go get a cup of coffee!
  • Taylor did, however, know exactly how to deal with Kitty refusing to talk to him -- she's physically incapable of sitting in silence.
  • Kitty to Robert, when he tells Taylor to wait while he gets cleaned up: "Honey, you need to hurry up -- I'm drowning in his smugness. And his aftershave."
  • Oh, poor Saul. He deserves so much better than these ungrateful Walker brats. I wanted to smack Sarah when she was acting all wounded  that Saul would betray her trust. That's what happens when you treat someone like a servant or an idiot for his entire life.
  • I'm all for supporting kids with cancer, but I'm kind of surprised the Walker family charity isn't liver transplants or cirrhosis research.
 
 
Zap2it Elite Sheet Must Reads from the Web's In-Crowd
 

Before David arrived, no one questioned whether Rebecca was a Walker (at least not since Kevin tried to yank her hair out at that dinner in Season 1). I think David believed that if he left, things could get back to the way they were. That's why "buggering off" would make things right, at least in his mind. Now Rebecca's the only one in town who knows the true paternity results, so as long as she doesn't spill the beans, she'll stay a Walker.

Emily Van Camp did a great job in this episode. Great performance. I love the chemistry between her and Justin. There's too much there for them to be related. The boys surfing and bantering about oxycodone and domestic partnership was good. Kitty gets on my nerves though.

I loved last night's twist. The show is doing a great job with this storyline. I'm excited.

Jump the shark.

Betraying the Rebecca storyline up to this point for the sake of a cheap plot twist is the worst thing one of my shows has ever done.

I was biding my time this year as the show got progressively worse, waiting for it to get good again. I can overlook a lot of crap if I love a show, but not this.

Emily VanCamp once again gave a TERRIFIC performance and rose above the awful material. But not even she can save this.

I'm done.

As far as I am concerned, the series now ended with the season one finale.

Jake,

I agree 100% with EVERYTHING you said! How could a show so great in season 1 crash and burn so quickly? The paternity thing was the nail in the coffin for me. Not to mention the Scotty/Kevin storyline. That just doesn't do it for me. I can't buy them as a couple. Kevin was much more believeable with Robert's brother. This whole Rebecca/Justin thing makes me want to hurl. Nora is nothing but grating lately, Sarah is a *****, Kitty and Robert's storyline is going nowhere, Saul seems stuck in no storyline hell along with Tommy and his poor wife who we never see.

What a shame. I used to LOVE this show.

I'm ***uming that off-camera, Rebecca asked David to leave. You could tell David was really torn up about leaving, and I ***ume he only left because his new found daughter asked him to.

I agree that Emily Van Camp did a great job, but this plot twist has soured me on the show.

With all of the whining all of the "fans" of this show who blog here do, one might suspect they are all Walkers.

I have to agree with Jake. This show is crashing, and quickly! I cannot believe a show I so adored would pull off a storyline like the Justin/Rebecca one. It was cheap and easy. I have always loved Justin, but his own sister. Creepy. And just because of the stupidness that is the DNA test results, they cannot hook up. I swore I wouldn't watch again if Rebecca wasn't a Walker, but I am willing to give it another chance. But if I see one bit of action between those two, I am out. I really mean it this time!

Why even have Rebecca and Holly on the show anymore? The show is about the Walker family and they have no ties to them anymore. They almost HAVE to have Justin and Rebecca hook up to even have a storyline for the two of them anymore. Having Rebecca not be a Walker is the stupidest move this show ever could have made. Who in the world thought that would be a good idea? It completely negates any investment we had in last year's main storyline. Stupid, stupid, stupid.

JAKE, i'd have to DIS-agree with you. Although i think the rebecca not being a walker story line is cheap and annoying, i do not think that the show is crashing and or burning, lol. When the news broke that she was in fact, Davids, i did shed a tear a litte, pound my bed with my fist(i was laying in my bed watching the show), and let out an explitive. However, i said, out of my loyalty to this show, i want to see where they take this. I stuck with them through Tommy's affair...which was aweful and i think i can stick with them through this. They def. beefed up the sexual tension between rebecca and justin last night and at the end of the episode i said to myself "ok maybe this might turn out to be good". It gives for a nice story arc through the end of the season...ya know...what will justin do about his feelings for his sister, does rebecca share those feelings, when will she drop the bomb that she's not a walker, will sarah go off on an elitist ramp of you've been hiding this secret all along...ya know.... I think everyone needs to take a step back and give them grace especially for returning with good stuff unlike other shows from the strike. In other news, i did like nora tonight AND THE WALKERS DIDNT REALLY GET INTO A BIG FIGHT.....YAY!!!!! I got nervous at the ball but it was safe. I WANT SCOTTY AND KEVIN TO DEAL MORE WITH THE MARRIAGE ISSUE....its political so i like it.

But whats going to happen with the family business, are we going to need tommy's help?

Post a comment

Find it fast
Zap2it Twitter Talk
Recent posts