'American Idol' voices Carey

April 15, 06:29 PM

For six-and-a-half seasons now, American Idol contestants have heard near-weekly lectures from the judges about how covering certain singers -- Whitney, Christina, Celine, Mariah -- is just a recipe for disaster, Tuesday (April 15) night's show is dedicated entirely to karaoke versions of Mariah Carey hits. Gee. That sounds like a recipe for disaster, right?

Singer: PRESUMPTIVE AMERICAN IDOL DAVID ARCHULETA
Song: "When You Believe"
My Take: Perhaps more than ever before, opening the show has been a death sentence this season. How did David Archuleta come to be performing first tonight, then? And, more importantly, how did he come to be wearing what appear to be leather pants? Ugh. I guess this wasn't the week for David to break out of his power balladeering mode, was it? Anybody remember the last time he looked like he was having fun? I only remember his eyes half-closed and his hand raised up urging viewers to follow him on his Children's March. Whether you're viewing David as remarkably consistent or remarkably monotonous is completely subjective at this point. I think he's aware that the only way he can lose is to make a horrible mistake and he has no interest in swaying new fans. I like how the only advice we saw Mariah give David was to go into his falsetto at the end. And that he didn't. Mariah Carey has no advice to give David Archuleta. [Note: At least one reader says David did the falsetto and I was just napping through it. I can't necessarily disagree.]
Garnett, Pierce and Simon Say: Randy was a little worried tonight, but he says that David can sing and therefore he can sing anything. This is factually inaccurate. Paula suspects that it's a huge honor for Mariah to hear David Archuleta sing her songs. Simon says he could have predicted the song choice, but that David performed it very well.

Singer: CARLY SMITHSON
Song: "Without You"
My Take: This is an interesting choice, because it's a song that pre-dates Mariah (not that you'd hear anybody mention "Harry Nilsson") and therefore hasn't been completely defined by Mariah. The song has a slow build and for a while there's a clear sense that Carly is holding herself back, trying to avoid over-singing. It's a decent strategy and it prevents some of the excess she's been prone to in her lesser moments. But do you really want to watch a performer who's only showing you a third of her performance capacity? And since this should, at least in theory, be a mighty emotional song, how are you supposed to connect to a cover where the singer's every thought is only "I'm trying not to yell at you"?
Garnett, Pierce and Simon Say: Randy urges her to check it out, but he cautions that she needs to trust herself in her lower register. Paula's a fan of the new-found the vocal restraint. Simon just doesn't think Carly can pull off the Mariah comparison. He suggests she's capable of pulling it off, but she's not confident enough.

Singer: SYESHA MERCADO
Song: "Vanishing"
My Take: This is a trap night for Syesha, whose every song choice this season has suggested a diva's confidence, if not the diva's ability. Dressed fetchingly in a tight gold evening gown, Syesha isn't taking the soft-sell here. The performance is almost nothing but runs and vibrato and vocal brinksmanship. It feels like a technical showcase more than a pure vocal performance and I think that if she had trusted the melody a bit more and showboated a bit less, it might have been better overall. That being said, there's obvious skill to what she's doing and there's also more risk-taking here than in either David or Carly's numbers. As Randy is so prone to saying, Syesha doesn't take the easy road.
Garnett, Pierce and Simon Say: Randy likes that she's bold and that all-things-considered she did a good job. Paula stammers something about Syesha's intelligence, raving it was "unbelievably magical." Simon would have chosen a song that more people know.

Singer: BROOKE WHITE
Song: "Hero"
My Take: Is Brooke going to win sympathy votes with the repetition of the story about missing her sister's wedding? And is anybody else slightly confused by why Brooke did "Hero" on the guitar at her mentoring session and then tickles the ivories tonight? It is, as you would expect, the low-key, Carly Simon-ized version of the song, lowering its degree-of-difficulty from an "9" in the Mariah version to maybe a "4." Even with the big notes scaled down, Brooke's nervousness is audible and the tight close-ups seem to capture some uncertain shaking. I continue to find something weird about the idea that Brooke's whole gimmick is doing middle-brow singer-songwriter versions of other people's songs. Have Carly Simon and Carole King released cover albums that I've missed? And leaving talent out of the equation, are this season's Idol singers the least versatile we've ever seen?
Garnett, Pierce and Simon Say: Randy likes that she brought the singer-songwriter side, but didn't like the bridge. Brooke totally admits that it's out there for her and she thanks him repeatedly. Paula goes into the same nattering about her authenticity, calling her version "brave." Brave? Brooke thanks Paula for recognizing her bravery. "It was a bit like ordering a hamburger and only getting the bun," Simon. Brooke is too confused to even thank Simon for making her hungry. Randy and Paula spend several minutes looking for the beef. A hamburger does sound good right now. Anybody want to join me at In-n-Out after the show?

Singer: KRISTY LEE COOK
Song: "Forever"
My Take: Don't look now, kids, but Kristy Lee Cook may be making her play to push David Cook to the side as Presumptive American Idol Runner-Up. She hasn't suddenly become more talented in recent weeks, but she's done a better job of working within her limitations. The country twang to the arrangement masks her pitchy moments well and she's impervious to the background singers who have become more and more obtrusive this season. She's a smidge mumbly and her performance style isn't much more than being serenely pretty. You know know, though, that the execs are figuring if Kellie Pickler can somehow become a successful and award-winning country artist, Kristy can as well.
Garnett, Pierce and Simon Say: Randy isn't calling it amazing, but she stepped it up at the ending. Paula's blown away, babbling away. Simon calls it "whiney," but says she made the most with a theme night that was never going to be an advantage. You know, I felt good about Kristy's performance at the beginning and it isn't three minutes later and I've forgotten it entirely. That's not good.

Singer: DAVID COOK
Song: "Always Be My Baby"
My Take: Thanks, David "The Leader" Cook. We would have figured you were thinking outside of the box without you praising your rebel instincts. The song is mostly unrecognizable in David's hands, but unlike what Brooke and Carly did, David's choices aren't based upon making the song less difficult. It starts off too low and I'm initially concerned it may crumble into a mess, but the second half is really strong. I also appreciate what Mariah calls the "unresolved" final note. He hits that great power note and then, just when you think it's done, there's a half-a-verse more to leave you wanting more. Forget what I said about Kristy. David's back atop the runner-up race.
Garnett, Pierce and Simon Say: Randy thinks David will be a hot recording artist and he actually seems to call it the season's best performance to date. Paula reckons the song belongs in a movie soundtrack. "It was like sort of coming out of karaoke hell into a breath of fresh air," Simon gushes. David is overcome by emotion at the end and for those unclear on the circumstances, the camera cuts to his ailing brother in the crowd. This is one of those moments where I won't make an accusation of showboating.

Singer: JASON CASTRO
Song: "I Don't Wanna Cry"
My Take: Has Enrique Iglesias does a version of this song? Because that's what this sounds like me. Now, frankly, I don't think Iglesias has a very good voice. Everything he sings sounds like it traveled into his mouth through some painful nasal passage and, like Clifford the Muppet, Iglesias has a tendency to make funny faces that make me think less of love songs and more of passing a kidney stone. But he's very successful and the ladies love him. That's probably the niche Jason wants to gun for and tonight may be the first time I've been able to see his commercial potential as something more than a loveable puppet.
Garnett, Pierce and Simon Say: Randy says it was like traveling to a weird beach luau and hearing somebody performing in the distance. Paula would love to be at that luau. Simon agrees with Paula. Simon also scores the evening as a victory for the men.

TONIGHT'S BEST: The combination of a strong and distinctive cover, plus the show of human emotion makes David Cook the night's best. Archuleta did his Archuleta thing. Syesha had a couple impressive runs. Jason didn't totally stink.

IN DANGER: Carly's had a couple close calls now and I think this week may be her time to go, with Syesha probably joining her in Bottom Three. That will leave one slot for either Brooke or Kristy. I think Brooke deserves it, but Kristy will take it.

Agree? Disagree? Was Mariah Carey Night better than you feared or worse?

And, as always, check out Zap2it's Guide to American Idol.

in American Idol , FOX

Permalink

Comments (93)

TrackBack (0)

Comments

I just wanna say Dan is amazingly efficient in writing the good commentary!

DT | Apr 15, 2008 6:36:54 PM | #

It's time. Both Syesha and Carly seem homeward bound to me. Which one goes is anybody's guess. David C. was tonight's best.

Jim E. | Apr 15, 2008 6:42:24 PM | #

David C. is always praised for changing a pop song into a rock song. Boring. He is fine, but is WAY overrated.

Lois | Apr 15, 2008 6:47:19 PM | #

Interesting show .. I was afraid it would be a show of veriah scariah Mariah wannabees. But there were some good moments in there. Props to David Cook who held it together despite the obvious emotions surrounding the evening.

Risa | Apr 15, 2008 6:49:25 PM | #

Hahaha, David A. was first and still stole the show! He's at the top on Dial Idol ;)

How's that for utter immunity? Death spot... right. This guy's immortal.

Samara | Apr 15, 2008 7:02:15 PM | #

David A's vocals were the best of the night by far. 8.5/10

David C mumbled a lot of his notes. There's singing softly and then there's mumbling. Still the arrangement is probably what America likes so he'll get a lot of praise for that. 8/10

Jason's arrangements are getting pretty monotonous as well. Still outperformed all the girls though. 7/10

Carly and KLC are always forgetable for me. combined 6/10

Daniel, you're right about Syesha taking a risk but that risk didn't pay off at all. All I heard was her belting out high note after high note and she actually drowned out the instruments. And the note she held sounded pretty off. 5/10

Hate to say it but it's probably gonna be bye bye Brooke 4/10

Hyvent | Apr 15, 2008 7:04:58 PM | #

I really liked the arrangement of David Cook's cover and he hit some impressive notes, but the first of that song and a lot of the middle and the very end were REALLY average. If he arranged that song, then props to him, but the performance was like a 6 or so. Brooke looked shaky.

Clark | Apr 15, 2008 7:26:09 PM | #

And it is past time for Syesha and Jason to go. They are beyond predictable and I have heard better than both at open mic night.

Clark | Apr 15, 2008 7:28:38 PM | #

Daniel, how do YOU feel about David A today? Consistent or monotonous? You were pretty ambiguous with your comments. And he did do his falsetto during,"when you belie-e-eve" near the end. It was very short though.

I just listened to David C's again and I'm less impressed the second time around. It's still pretty good but he's very off on the vocals in the first half. The ending saved it.

Hyvent | Apr 15, 2008 8:01:44 PM | #

I was impressed that Syesha chose "Vanishing". I was sure she'd pick a more recognizable power ballad, like "Vision of Love" or something.

I thought Brooke was the night's worst. I don't think she'll go home though. Ugh.

Siansonea | Apr 15, 2008 8:07:58 PM | #

Hyvent -- Is it a cop-out if I say "both" in response to your question? While I obviously have my favorites each season, I try to be as objective as possible in my reviews each week. On the level that functions empirically, I admire David's consistency and I know how hard it is to be solid each and every week.

On the level, though, where I want the show to entertain me, I find it a bit frustrating how unchanging he is and how he hasn't tried branching out since he butchered that Stevie Wonder cover of the Beatles song. He's like a football team playing a Prevent Defense at this point. He's singing not to lose, rather than to win.

Or that's just my opinion.

-Daniel

Daniel | Apr 15, 2008 8:24:48 PM | #

I think Syesha's song title might end up being prophetic tomorrow. I know she has a good voice but seems like she doesn't connect to the audience well. Carly and Jason join her in my bottom 3 but I know that isn't how it will go down.

I liked the Cook's as the top 2 tonight

man | Apr 15, 2008 8:24:53 PM | #

Daniel, I agree 100 percent about David A. playing prevent defense. But someone should tell him that all the prevent defense does is prevents winning. On second thought...no one tell him.

3man | Apr 15, 2008 8:27:02 PM | #

No it's not a cop-out. I appreciate that more than people who hate him just because he's the same every week and don't appreciate the actual quality of his performances. And yes the prevent defense may cost him in the end.

Oh, and yep this has gotta be the least versatile group ever. Carly is probably the most versatile but that's what's gonna be her downfall because she's too damn confused.

Hyvent | Apr 15, 2008 8:53:49 PM | #

I am absolutely over the moon that Mariah Careyfinally did American Idol, it's about damn time. Great for her fans, maybe not so much for female Idol contestants. To me, David Cook's performance was the undoubtedly the best. He made a great pop song become haunting. I don't think he's overrated at all, and now, he is definitely David A's main competition.

I agree that it might be Carly's time to go home because her performance was just a mess when compared to Mariah's version. I think she should've shouted and emoted it more , better overdoing it than restraining when it comes to this song, just IMO. Country fans will keep Kristy for one more week, Syesha might be in the bottow 3 along with Brooke's overly understated shaky performance.

Lastly, I guess I have to endure one more week of Jason Castro. That's too bad.

Ritchie | Apr 15, 2008 9:05:41 PM | #

"Without You" was originally done by Badfinger.

Marc | Apr 15, 2008 10:00:59 PM | #

Well Daniel David Archuleta did a falsetto at the end, weren't you paying attention, isn't that what you are getting paid to do, details honey!!! C'mon, even us folks noticed he did...David A. keeps on impressing me each week. Consistent always and that'a probably why I like him....I'd buy his cd oh wait I've already downloaded all his songs from iTunes!!!

1. David Archuleta
2. David Cook
3. Brooke White
4. Jason Castro
5. Carly Smithson
6. Kristy Lee Cook
7. Sayesha Mercado

Ariel | Apr 15, 2008 10:21:37 PM | #

It will be a travesty if Carly goes home before Kristy Lee, Syesha, or even Jason. For once it would be nice to see Simon give her some constructive criticism, having been excessively hard on her all season long. Now the judges' comments boil down to "Be confident in yourself", which is ridiculous considering week after week (in spite of doing far better than some past wretched performances by Kristy, Ramielle, Syesha, Jason, and others) they've joyfully torn her down piece by piece telling her how she doesn't look good or sound good. I don't think Simon has wanted her to come close to winning from day one. Hopefully some good producer and writer out there will see the potential in her voice and nurture her skills.

And on a side note, what's up with the A-holes at American Idol not giving Brooke one single day off to go to her sister's wedding? Really? They can't spare her one day of pimping this gazillion dollar show to go to a once in a lifetime family event? That's awfully petty on the producers' part.

Jen | Apr 15, 2008 10:28:11 PM | #

Unless an iTunes search of "Always Be My Baby" returns with some random Mariah cover by an obscure rock band, I'm going to maintain that David Cook was nothing short of brilliant tonight. I loved how he changed the tone of the song, and I have to agree with Paula...that version would fit right at home in a big studio romantic flick. In my opinion, it was one of the best Idol performances ever, and definitely the best of the season.

On a different note, I thought Kristy was easily the worst of the night. There were some good moments, but there were also some very bad moments as well (and a lot more of them). Plus, her timing was off during the chorus and that really annoyed me. If anyone else goes but her tomorrow, it'll be another unjustified elimination this week.

Dennis | Apr 15, 2008 11:13:05 PM | #

I don't think she'll go home this week because her personality gets her some votes, but I thought Brooke had the worst performance tonight. She's been one of my favorites since the original auditions, but she seemed very timid throughout, and the result was a bland and disjointed performance.

Nobody blew me away tonight, but I'd go with the Davids as the top two performances. For the bottom three, Sayesha and Kristi safe, Carly going home.

| Apr 15, 2008 11:37:39 PM | #

David C. is currently on top at DialIdol.com.

Erika | Apr 16, 2008 2:12:00 AM | #

Yo, check it out.Carly Simon did indeed do a cd of covers last year.

Mooriah | Apr 16, 2008 3:45:57 AM | #

Let's grade the remaining 7 for Mariah Carey week:

David A - A (another great job)

David C - D (awful, unbearable to listen to)

Syesha - C (try picking songs we know and stop trying to oversing them, honey)

Brooke - D (awful, just plain bad)

Jason C - D (awful, he really needs to just go home)

Carly - B (she actually did a fairly decent job with it)

Kristy Lee - C (not as bad as David, Brooke or Jason, but not as good as in the past few weeks)

Should be in the bottom 3: Brooke, Syesha, Jason or Kristy

Simon C | Apr 16, 2008 4:34:07 AM | #

I hated David Cook's version of the song. He is the one who has become predictable. Did anyone not think he would take an uptempo song, slow it down, mumble the words, then scream some long notes at the end? How many times has he done this?

I thought David Archuleta was the best of the night by far. I wish these reviews didn't seem like there was a bone to pick going on versus an honest assessment of what happened. David did use his falsetto at the end so how are we supposed to trust you were even paying attention?

Aaron Kreider | Apr 16, 2008 4:35:57 AM | #

Carly with her "It's so nice to meet you, Mariah", and "it's been a dream come true" when she HAS ALREADY MET HER, was baffling. She's gonna keep burying her planty past in an effort to keep people from realizing she's already bombed and is ticking away once again.

Frank Rook | Apr 16, 2008 4:56:49 AM | #

I realy enjoyed KLC tonight.

David Cook was incredible.

Bottom 3:
Brooke, Syesha & Carly.

Jason deserves to be there and be out of here.

But, I think we won't see Brooke anymore.

| Apr 16, 2008 5:36:45 AM | #

David Cook was horrible. It was every bit as lousy and awful as last week.

Amy | Apr 16, 2008 5:43:47 AM | #

Daniel F.--Do you know if the Idol contestants get paid while on the show? What about while on tour? Just curious.

Shira | Apr 16, 2008 5:55:04 AM | #

It amazes me that people think David Cook is horrible. Dude has stage presence and can arrange a great song around his voice and style. David Archuleta may have a good voice (which is debatable, he's good in slow ballads but sucks in anything up-tempo) but he has ZERO stage presence. Ask him to move around at all on stage and he forgets words or mumbles them.

And David Cook mumbling? Turn up your TV or your hearing aid's. He's not mumbling, it's singing softly and hauntingly. I clearly understood every word.

Josh | Apr 16, 2008 6:04:56 AM | #

All 3 guys were great. They know who they are and have distinctive styles. I might be one of the only ones who doesnt think they need to prove extreme diversity week after week. When they record an album, it will be pretty much in one style. For me, all I ask for is a strong voice, good performance quality and stage presence and to believe they genuinely love music. In this competiton, good song choices and a little creativity really helps. David Cook is my favorite and will be fine even if he doesnt make the finals. Yea, he keeps a rock style, but that's what his record will be. I like the tone of his voice and the fact he can make a song sound completely different from the original in his own distinct way. That is the sign of a great musician and artist. Still think it will be David-David finale. Jason does what he does well and his fans love his style.
........
Unfortunately for the girls, they are harder to connect with and identify. I thought they all were better than what Randy and Simon did though. Kristy has gotten smarter and stronger AND she has her identity- I think she will go farther than she probably should based on just talent. I thought she did well. The rest have made poor choices too many times, which is their problem. Syesha has skill but still isn't connecting as aperformer. Carly has made so many poor choices in song and unfortunately comes off a bit desperate to me. I thought she was good though last night and the judges were a bit harsh. I think she has a good voice but she looks awkward when she sings high and doesnt seem to know how to best use her vocal skills- which is a problem for an artist. And Brooke hasn't done well in many weeks, I've lost interest. She doesnt have range so she needs to be that much smarter in choices.
.......
Dialidol has it exactly right, in my opinion. Bottom 3 will be Carly, Syesha, and Brooke with either Brooke or Syesha leaving.

Erin | Apr 16, 2008 6:05:02 AM | #

Love The Cooks, David and Kristy. People are so hard on KLC. There have been much worst people in past seasons far worst. At least she can sing. She will do well in Country, I might go as far to say she will be BIG within the next 2 years or so.

Ray | Apr 16, 2008 6:06:06 AM | #

David Cook was great. I thought the beginning was a little off but he really impressed me when he wrapped up that song. I'm going to download it today! Nobody beats Mariah's version of ANY of the songs sung last night IMO.
I actually thought KLC did a decent version of "Forever". That's one of my favorite Mariah songs. She may still be bottom 3 but, she didn't suck.
Carly also did a decent job with that song. Poor thing, one week she's told not to scream or oversing and the next week, when she doesn't scream or oversing she's accused of holding back. She looked pretty defeated after the comments last night.
Brooke.....honey, belt it out, PLEASE!!!! She's one chick that needs to let loose and not hold back.
Jason please go home Ugh. He actually sounded OK when I turned my head so I didn't have to look at him...kinda '90's boy bandish.
David A was just like Simon said he was, great and predictable.
Syesha did do a lot of runs and she impressed me with her big notes but, I already forgot about her. I almost missed writing my thoughts about her but, then I counted how many and I was one short.
Bottom 3: Syesha, Brooke and, Hopefully Jason but, probably Carly...with Brooke going home.

Chris | Apr 16, 2008 6:15:20 AM | #

DAVID ARCHULETA IS GAY

obviously | Apr 16, 2008 6:19:45 AM | #

I thought the two David's were the best tonight. David A was consistant and David C daring. It reminded me of when Marty Casey had to do a Britney Spears song on Rockstar INXS - he flipped it and nailed it.

Jason C is starting to grow on me. I didn't totally hate it tonight. You're right about him having that think the Enrique has - not much to do with singing talent but it will get him far.

I agree with Simon that the guys won. KLC was okay, Siyesha did too many runs and not enough melody. Carly did try restraint but this was not the song to do it on, and Brooke was a bundle of nerves that got the better of her. Three ladies in the bottom three this week, I think. It could be any of them going home.

Caz

Caz | Apr 16, 2008 6:27:14 AM | #

I am tired of Brooke's singing and personality, and her insipid and flat Hero showed her limitations (yes, I know the two Davids, KLC, and Jason stylize every song the same way, but at least the two Davids can both really sing, KLC is passable and pretty; have no idea why Jason is still here; he can't hold a candle vocally to any of the other men inc. Chiz, DH, and MJ). Carly is low and rumbly every song and needs to present herself better; KLC and Sye may not be vocally better, but they at least are beginning to look like celebs. Carly, Brooke, Sye in bottom 3 with Brooke or Carly departing.

John | Apr 16, 2008 6:28:17 AM | #

Wow! Very cynical overview. Sounds like someone p****d in your cheerios! What the heck are they supposed to do with Mariah Carey songs? Whoever thinks of these particular theme nights should be shot. They are incredibly awful and stupid!! Michael Johns got out a good time...next week Andrew Lloyd Weber?? Yikes!!

D | Apr 16, 2008 6:37:46 AM | #

I agree with the comment about lack of versatility this season, despite all the talk about it being the most talented group. There is great talent, still I could see Fantasia, Melinda Doolittle, Jodan Sparks (even Blake Lewis,though probaby not doing a very good job)at least attempting an upbeat or later Mariah song
like Fantasy, Heartbreaker or We Belong Together. I love Mariah, it's just that we had one mid-tempo early balad after another. Even an attempt at "Someday' would have been fun.

Bob | Apr 16, 2008 7:01:25 AM | #

Dial Idol Looks like this

In the Green
1. David Cook
2. David A
3 Jason
4 Kristy

In the Yellow
5. Carly
6. Brooke
7. Syesha

The one in the bottom almost never goes home I think Ramielle was the only one who was at the bottom that actually went home.

Michael was 4th from the bottom last week but in the yellow so I'm going to guess its Carly that will be gone

mike | Apr 16, 2008 7:11:21 AM | #

David Archuletta is a TOTAL BORE!

I don't like Kristy, but his performance sucked compared to hers. They are pimping him out big time. His notes were off, he was pitchy, and the performance was safe.

Cook was leaps and bounds the best, and Syeesha knows her shit - but they stab her in the back week after week.

bob | Apr 16, 2008 7:19:35 AM | #

So Clark, the first part, the middle, and the end of David Cook's song were all average ... just exactly which part is it that you liked?

Beth | Apr 16, 2008 7:31:59 AM | #

How can you complain about David A being pitchy yet not blast David C for it? David C's vocals were terrible except for 2 notes. I'll give him his due for PICKING a cool arrangement and for performing under stressful conditions.
And as for Syesha, just wait till the bottom 3 is announced tonite and see who America agrees with.

chuck | Apr 16, 2008 7:39:24 AM | #

I agree with most of the posts here. David A. is a big bore. No matter the theme, no matter the mentor, his song choices are always slow boring yawn-inducing ballads.

I just don't get the attraction. But then I'm not a 12-year old pre-pubescent girl.

David Cook is far and away the best of the bunch. He always takes risks and they pay off. Even if David Cook does not win, he'll have the kind of success that fourth place finisher Daughtry has had.

My bottom 3 predictions:
Carly, Kristi and Syesha. Don't care who goes home. The final two will most likely be boys. Maybe even a pair of dueling "Davids".

Peace.

JVice | Apr 16, 2008 7:41:27 AM | #

David Cook is by far the most overrated person in the remaining 7. Just because he takes risks doesn't mean he's the "best", because for the past two weeks, his "risks" (including last night) sounded AWFUL. Simon is always right-on when he criticizes David Cook for his smugness and arrogance. The guy is good and he knows it.

David Archuleta has a very strong, very powerful, and very clear voice, which puts him head and shoulders above the rest.

Raheel Jackson | Apr 16, 2008 7:47:24 AM | #

DAVID COOK SUCKS!!!!!!!

Susan | Apr 16, 2008 7:48:28 AM | #

David A. is a bore. And everyone knows it. He puts me to sleep eveytime.

David C. is the best of the bunch. He's not arrogant. He's sure of himself and very confident.

JVice | Apr 16, 2008 7:53:57 AM | #

Mooriah -- Carly Simon has done several (four or five?) albums of "standards," but I don't count raiding the Cole Porter songbook as doing a cover album. I know that may be semantics, but still... Even if she had, though, it would have been a late-career stunt after 30 years of developing a reputation as a singer-songwriter and establishing a specific and personal voice and tone.

Shira - I *believe* that contestants are given stipends/compensation for both the season and the time on tour. I couldn't tell you an exact figure. It isn't much, but since they're given room and board, perhaps it adds up in the long run?

And again, I apologize for missing Archuleta's falsetto that I'm assured took place. I'm not sure who I'm apologizing to, but I'm sure I'm sorry.

Now back to the Cook vs. Archuleta Battle Royale.

-Daniel

Daniel | Apr 16, 2008 7:59:20 AM | #

Btw: I don't know about Carole King, but Carly Simon HAS released a few albums of covers... some of them quite lovely.

And how come no one has mentioned publicity wh*re Teri Hatcher sitting right behind Randy?

JeffH | Apr 16, 2008 8:01:34 AM | #

David C is NOT the best of the bunch. He's highly arrogant and for the past few weeks his arrangements and performances have been unbearable to listen to. He thinks too much of himself.

Basically, he just sucks.

T-Dog | Apr 16, 2008 8:03:42 AM | #

I think Jason is so overrated. I can't even hear him over the band, I had my TV turned more than halfway up in a quiet room and I still couldn't hear his vocals. I think he is as bad as Sanjaya last year and is also being kept in by the teeny bopper girls who think he's cute. He seems like a really nice young man, but he really needs to go soon.

ihatepaula | Apr 16, 2008 8:08:41 AM | #

wow. I really don't think David a. is all that. he's too boring and that fake humble face he always has. WTF? go home already so dad can put you back in the cage!!!

david YAWN chuleta | Apr 16, 2008 8:22:26 AM | #

David Cook served up some pure food poisoning last night! Doesn't America have ears that work? That was just plain awful. After two hideously bad performances in a row, even the memory of the ripped off Billie Jean can't resurrect this guy. He should definitely be OUTTA THERE! Jason was outstanding!

Magnetis | Apr 16, 2008 8:23:27 AM | #

DANIEL: I agree with you that the AI producers were basically setting up a "David VS David" finale since the final 12 were chosen. I don't think the producers really care about the other contestants, as long as both Davids make it to the finals. Let's face it: they will have the different demographics covered. Younger fans (mostly teenage girls) will watch and vote for Archuleta. Probably more mature viewers will vote for Cook's rocker style. Also, They might want to keep Kristy around to appeal to country fans.

I agree that this season's contestants are probably less versatile than in past seasons. However, both Cook and Archuleta have strong voices and raw talent. The women seem inconsistent from week to week. Brooke sounded shaky, and she did speed up the song at the end.

I wasn't too impressed with anyone's versions of Mariah, except for David Cook. I was really afraid that he would mess up by slowing it down too much, but I was pleasantly surprised. Mariah said it best when she commented that David's version was more "haunting" from a man's perspective. I know a lot of people say he is too predictable, but this week his arrangment actually worked for me.

JEFF H.: I noticed Teri Hatcher right away, and I founf it too distracting. I don't care if celebrities want to sit in the studio audience, but please don't seat them right behind the judges. After all, Teri is the star from an ABC show, NOT FOX! I kept thinking that the ABC execs must be loving the free publicity for Desperate Housewives. I would rather see more of the contestants' family members in that section of the theater.

Paige | Apr 16, 2008 8:41:33 AM | #

Thank GOD Mariah night is over!

Michael | Apr 16, 2008 8:43:19 AM | #

Thank God for sensible posts like Paiges that aren't so obviously biased.

David C seems arrogant only when he sings. He has a smirk on his face a lot of times (although I didn't notice it in last night's performance). He's quieted down in the last while when he's talking to the judges and Ryan. He's probably the 2nd smartest (next to KLC) for picking the right songs and arrangements and knowing how to entertain. I'm not the biggest fan but he's got America hooked.

David A DOES have potential to do a "fun" song as seen in his Shop Around performance although he sure hasn't shown it lately. It's all about song choice for him. I'd say he's 2nd dumbest (next to Syesha) for picking predictable/boring songs. And especially last night. The song disappointed me but the performance was great. And how can you say his humility is fake? There ARE some people in the world who are that nice. He's shown nothing but humility every single week and in all videos of him. And if you think he gets caged at home, don't you think that'll humble you just a little bit?

With both of them, you can tell they're both progressing (to some extent). David C doesn't talk back anymore and David A isn't "aw shucks" and lip licking anymore.

Poor Daniel is getting bashed for one little mistake. Don't worry, David's falsetto was not worth remembering.

hyvent | Apr 16, 2008 8:47:31 AM | #

A reason I like David A is b/c seeing him grow from Star Search is interesting, but Dan's right, not taking any risks in either his vocal takes or choices, even the funner, uptempo songs other than maybe Shop Around are "Message" type songs. I can't decide whether David A winning is better or David C winning is better since 19 owns these kids-- Clay broke his Idol contract, and someone told me that Kelly C did too to own her own name and its use. I'd like to see them both grow on their own without the smothering of a Clive Davis who may try to turn them into saccharine artists when they are capable of so much more. Kind of like how I think Clay can be so much more than his shallow covers album, but we'll see what the new album brings in May. Maybe it's best if neither David wins and Sye or KLC win instead?

John | Apr 16, 2008 9:06:03 AM | #

Vanishing is one of my favorite Mariah songs (back when she used to sing, and not try and be some hip-hop ho). But i digress, people don't know that the song has a lot of runs, and i thought Syesha did a fairly good job for a nearly impossible cover. Why do people have to cover well-known stylized songs in order to get votes? They will only fall flat to comparison. Does anyone remember Kelly Clarkson covering a much better version of "Without You?"

Heartbreaker | Apr 16, 2008 9:23:45 AM | #

If David Cook has become predictable, then David Archuleta is far beyond predictable! The kid (yeah I said kid) does a ballad everyweek, because if he doesn't, he forgets the words to the song.

Eric | Apr 16, 2008 9:29:22 AM | #

David A. = SNORE ZZZZZZZ
KLC = Bye Bye
Syesha = Divawannabeya
The rest = CD's I would actually buy-

rubytoo | Apr 16, 2008 9:33:56 AM | #

David A might choose 'boring' songs, but his voice and personality are miles above the competition.
I agree that Kristi L Cook is the runner up; Syesha is kinda boring.
I like Carly, but she always seems to be straining her voice. Brooke was plain awful tonight.
David Cook CANNOT sing the low notes and his performances have gone down since billy jean. Not that I liked him to begin with.
Jason... why is he still in the competition?!? and what is Simon smoking?!? prasing this guy?!? Man, I really hope this hippie finally gets kicked out this week. Sanjaya was better than this guy!

edgar | Apr 16, 2008 9:37:15 AM | #

I seriously voted for Carly for 2 hours straight, which I have never done. I vote, but never for the whole time. I really hope she stays.

MDEP | Apr 16, 2008 9:41:12 AM | #

never do Mariah, Whitney, or Celine unless we can make bucks off it.

Not a bad night

David A. did what he always does and sounded good. But I can't see myself buying an album of his.

Carly played it safe, she sounded fine but it was a little bland. May have made right choice on holding back though.

Syesha, talk about being in her "wheel house" I agree Simon that Syesha was technically good, but she has a hard time connecting with the audience & songs.

Brooke, sorry but was the worst performance of the night. She completely lost the song about midway through and didn't recover. "where's the beef" WTF??

I thought Kristy actually performed well on a night that wasn't natural for her. She hit some strong notes at the end. Kristy has got a powerful voice but needs the confidence to use it. Seemed Simon had written his critique of KLC last week, because he knew "the country girl" wouldn't do well on Mariah night and couldn't wait to bring it up. Especially considering the joking criticism of Brooke and "no meat".

Wow David Cook is back after a weak performance last week. Judges are correct, David is ready to record an album and it may be big; I mean Daughtery big.

I admit I don't get Jason. This performance was awful in my view. After two straight wonderful reviews by Simon, I'm convinced that Jason has pictures of Simon and a goat.

Overall, I say David Cook stole the night with David A. behind him. Syesha, and Kristy Lee in the middle. With Jason and Carly slightly behind them. But worst of night goes to Brooke.

Bottom three Brooke, Carly and Syesha or perhaps Kristy after Simons' critique. Based on last night, Brooke should go home.

jbw | Apr 16, 2008 9:42:16 AM | #

I have not missed one show.
In my opinion these four don't have what it takes.
Carly
Brooke
Syesha
Kristy

The guy's have the most talent this season.

Kudo's for all the work you guys did raising money for a good cause!

Gary | Apr 16, 2008 9:42:36 AM | #

I think to anyone over 21, David Archuleta is very hard to stomach. He has about as much personality as the paperweight on my desk. But he's cute, and he can sing. My 10 year old loves him. She also enjoys chocolate milk on Lucky Charms.

I thought KLC would bow out this week, but her countrified song was better than the more powerful Carly, was more in touch than the normally connected Brooke, and wasn't as showy as Syesha, who just needed to do what she normally would do best to survive. I think Dial Idol has it right this week. KLC will have to pick a different week to slink off.

Word Money G | Apr 16, 2008 9:47:55 AM | #

Great comments Heartbreaker. I definitely remember Kelly Clarkson's version of "Without You" - one of the best performances on Idol, ever.

I also like the old Mariah as well.

Daniel, I love every word you write. You're the best!

Jeff | Apr 16, 2008 9:49:24 AM | #

OK.HERE IS THE STRAIGHT DEAL..KLCook can sing, she is very pretty and Simon needs to get a life..he constantly kicks her ass...I thing Simon needs to get layed. David A is good but over rated and David Cook is orginial but does not have the best voice. He will have a record contract even if he does not come in as # 1. I also think that this is set up as every week the judges love Jason and he really sucks.I am really starting to get tired of the judges..Randy, Paula..I know she tries to make nice with everyone and Simon who things he knows everything..well if we had his money we would too.

BATMAN | Apr 16, 2008 9:49:36 AM | #

Going into the show, there were four women and three men remaining. Having to perform Mariah Carey songs ensures one of the women will be dismissed and balance the field as we head down the stretch.

Aren't there more brilliant female singer/songwriters they can use? Carol King? Sheryl Crow?

I can't recall...have the finalists had to do a night of songs by a specific male artist yet (other than the Beatles)?

Time to say bye bye to Brooke.

Richard | Apr 16, 2008 9:56:21 AM | #

Well I think, Jason, Kristi and Syesha needs to be in the bottome three. I feelKristi needs to go. Hew fakeness bothers me. Its all on looks with her. She really needs to go. Carly has a magnificant voice and I feel Mariah's songs did her no justice. I hope America will se the good in her. She by far as the best vocal of all the women. I hope America will see the good in her.

Michael Mangan | Apr 16, 2008 9:56:28 AM | #

Michael Mangan | Apr 16, 2008 9:56:37 AM | #

I am enjoying watching KLC get better and more confident each week. Good for her. She is smart with her song choices and not arrogant.

She won't be gone this week.

I wish Carly would of held the end of her song better, that hurt her.

I don't get Jason.

Brooke was awful, she looke scared.

Syesha has a great voice but tries to be to showy and sing songs she shouldn't.

I think Brooke or Carly are gone.

| Apr 16, 2008 10:14:52 AM | #

So am I

Obvious | Apr 16, 2008 10:32:46 AM | #

I honestly do not get when people say David C can't sing. He has such a fantastic voice. His is the only album I'll be buying. You couldn't pay me to listen to that twerp David A or that stoner Jason.

Lisa | Apr 16, 2008 10:34:32 AM | #

I agree with the two posters above who mentioned Kelly's version of "Without You." When Kelly sang it, she MEANT it and I was blown away. When Carly sang it, I just thought about how I really liked it when Kelly sang the song. I appreciate that Carly has a good voice, but I don't actually believe or enjoy her performances. She should be in the bottom three with Brooke, who was way out of her league last night, and I suppose anyone other than a David.

I didn't know there was anything wrong with his brother, but David Cook rocked the house again.

David A should try another upbeat song, and Syesha should try another Tobacco Road gravelly-sounding song.

Cindy | Apr 16, 2008 10:35:29 AM | #

Thank You for Mentioning Harry Nilsson. Without will always be his song. I have thankfully never heard the Mariah Version. is every artist who appears on this show brillant? good..yes popular..definitely...brilliant???....not so much.....

George Kahwaty | Apr 16, 2008 10:39:50 AM | #

Last night's episode wasn't as much of a trainwreck as I was expecting...

katie71483 | Apr 16, 2008 10:55:38 AM | #

"And leaving talent out of the equation, are this season's Idol singers the least versatile we've ever seen?"

True, also when have the judges allowed the singers to show such a lack of versatility and not criticize them for it. David Archuleta Syesha, Brook and Jason perform the same way ever week.

It | Apr 16, 2008 11:04:59 AM | #

I think it will be Brooke, Syesha and Carly in the bottom three with Brooke going home. Mariah songs just aren't Carly's type of songs, Syesha's choice "Vanishing" is something I didn't even know Mariah recorded and Brooke was completely out of her element and seemed very nervous.

Penny | Apr 16, 2008 11:27:00 AM | #

Way too much to comment on! Just wanted to say that I actually think KLC has showed improvement over the past few weeks. That doesn't mean I think she should win; I'm just saying! HOWEVER, she's no Kellie Pickler! That child has a dynamite personality and I haven't detected even a mediocre one from KLC.

Jan | Apr 16, 2008 11:52:58 AM | #

I can't believe that I'm saying this, but I actually teared up listening to David Cook's performance last night. I have never cried watching American Idol before, but I really felt genuine emotion from DC. Personally, I hate it when contestants cry after they perform, as I think it's just pandering for sympathy votes. Not so with DC last night. I loved the "twist" that he put on a MC song that is normally so up-beat.

Honestly, I still think that Archuleta might have a better chance at winning, but DC's performance should put him in second place at least. The rest of the singers were pretty forgettable. No one was particularly awful, but maybe Brooke shouldn't have tried to do "Hero".

Sandi | Apr 16, 2008 12:08:58 PM | #

I am glad to know that I am not the only one who thought that Brooke seemed to be shaking while she was singing last night.

It is very hard for me to understand why there is so much hostility directed toward these contestants. I am not a 12-18 year old, way, way ,way past that age group, but I enjoy listening to David A. I do not like rock, but I have nothing against David Cook. I truly enjoy listening to Kristy. As for tonight I will find out who is sent home when I hear Ryan say, tonight we say goodbye to ( ) Nothing can shock me now after last weeks dismissal of Michael Johns.

Trupen | Apr 16, 2008 12:14:44 PM | #

Here's the deal. The boys flattened the girl last night, there's no question about it. The two Davids and Jason easily will cruise to next week. The girls? Brooke was actually better than people realized and will be safe. Put that down. Syesha will also be safe too. They were quite decent. It's either going to be Carly or Kristy Lee. You can't possibly believe they both rescued themselves last night. They were just okay for me dawg.

Shaun | Apr 16, 2008 12:39:39 PM | #

Here's the deal. The boys flattened the girls last night, there's no question about it. The two Davids and Jason easily will cruise to next week. The girls? Brooke was actually better than people realized and will be safe. Put that down. Syesha will also be safe too. They were quite decent. It's either going to be Carly or Kristy Lee. You can't possibly believe they both rescued themselves last night. They were just okay for me dawg.

Shaun | Apr 16, 2008 12:40:05 PM | #

me again.

"david a. has a personality". please let me know where it is cause i haven't seen it.

he's ok, but please, he's not the best of these kids. and i'm not old. i'm 17 and still think he's boring. i'd liek to see david cook win it all. he rocks!!!

david YAWN chuleta | Apr 16, 2008 12:49:43 PM | #

Gosh, by looking at these comments, i'm glad i tuned in for Biggest Loser. Looks like i didn't miss much.

Tina S | Apr 16, 2008 1:08:47 PM | #

I cant comment on the performances last night as I didnt watch. Not because I was busy but because I cant stand Mariah Carey.

Im not real thrilled about a Andrew Lloyd Weber night either.Dont get me wrongm if you are going to do a broadway night cover them all. If I hear one more song from Phantom or Cats I think Ill scream. (give me Rent of Fosse or Showboat anytime)

I do find it interesting the various reasons some people come up with for not likeing a singer. This one grins too much while he sings or someones tatoo is distracting or she is too tall or too short. Come on lets judge the voices not the looks. If you dont like the faces someone makes while they sing close your eyes. You dont watch them while listening to a cd. Judge properly or dont comment at all.

darrpub | Apr 16, 2008 1:27:44 PM | #

david archuleta is awsome! i love him! and he always does an AHHHHmazing job each week...and just so you know ( he did in fact go into his falceto in the end, so you must have been naping throught it..although i dont know why)!

samantha | Apr 16, 2008 3:04:42 PM | #

omg people whats with bashing on davind a? hes better than any of those contestants on idol this year and he sooo does have personality, you people jsut need to pay more attention!

rachel | Apr 16, 2008 3:07:11 PM | #

Is anyone else on the boards aware of the Heart version of "Without You"? It was on their 1978 album "Magazine". It's really good.

I thought Carly was borrowing from that version at first, but she ended up doing a three-way cross between Heart, Mariah and Nillson.

Siansonea | Apr 16, 2008 3:36:20 PM | #

Jason.....Time to pack it up bro! YOU, are the weakest link!

ray | Apr 16, 2008 4:04:13 PM | #

Frank Rook - Have you ever met a star or someone before and if you met them again you don't mention you have met them before? I have.

I have. It's a weird social situation. There could be a million reasons she didn't say she met her before. Uh maybe she's embarrassed of her album failing. If that's the case, so freaking what. She's a human being.

You are a D-bag!!!!!!!!

Jason S. | Apr 16, 2008 4:26:02 PM | #

I hate these idiotic individual singer theme nights! Invariably, it is obvious that one or two singers are so out of their elements. This week, it was Brooke. IMO, her voice and Mariah's are at opposite ends of the vocal spectrum.
But all that aside, would somebody please shut Paula up - or at least, but a brief time limit on her gushing nothingness? Like him or not, Simon usually has something either funny, insightful or irritating to say and he gets shorted because Paula takes 5 minutes just to say someone's pretty, authentic or some other meaningless comment.

MGC | Apr 16, 2008 4:27:10 PM | #

You know what's cool about David Cook.

His brother is dying of cancer and was at the show last night and he doesn't use it as a sympathy vote getter.

He is cool, genuine, and believable.

Best contestant ever on idol. Even better then Daughtry to when I saw thought this guy is pretty cool for idol.

David Cook is just cool period. Doesn't matter if the 12-15 year olds vote for Archuletta instead because Cook will be signed and he's better off not winning like Daughtry.

Jason S. | Apr 16, 2008 4:29:52 PM | #

I agree about Kristy's career will kick into high gear whenever she leaves Idol. The camera loves her! On another matter, this column needs to learn the true definition of a COVER RECORD. It does NOT mean recording a song years later that was previously by another artist. Use the internet and be informed.

Danny | Apr 16, 2008 5:54:26 PM | #

I have listened to David Cook's full song Studio version..Always My Baby, Eleanor Rigby, Little Sparrow, Don't Say A word. One word - awesome! I only hope for great success for this guy..

nina | Apr 17, 2008 3:02:00 AM | #