'X-Factor': Cheryl Cole ousted over her accent? Plus, would you rather see Nicole Scherzinger?

Please... anyone but Nicole! She has a great voice, but did you see her judge on The Sing Off? It was embarrassing to watch!

I was curious to see Cole. Don't have anything against the Pussycat Doll, but if there's a mentoring element I'm not sure she's the best fit. I mean, she's tried at least 6 times to launch a solo career unsuccessfully, despite having visibility from the PCD and then Dancing with the Stars. Not sure she has the best...instincts, I guess you could say.

Neither Cheryl or Nicole should have the job Cheryl is a nobody and Nicole is a total flop. Simon needs to hire a famous US singer with talent. I wouldn't be surprise if Mariah ends up being replacing Nicole for the live shows. Most America's don't like to watch Nicole she's annoying.

I'd rather Cheryl. I've watched Britain's THE X FACTOR online (for several years now) and enjoy Cheryl's presence. I've never had difficulty understanding her, and in fact LOVE her accent. She's plenty glamourous. Nicole is fine, and I didn't mind her as a judge on THE SING OFF, but I'd prefer Cheryl.

she's beautiful, much easier on the eyes than paula.

I trust Simon's instincts. I was looking forward to seeing Cheryl. She's beautiful, classy, experienced, and her voice is lovely. Nicole seemed lovely on DWTS but was awkward and a potty-mouth as a judge on The Sing Off. Cheryl is best for the judge's seat, allowing Nicole the opportunity to redeem herself as the host.

agree with ck. nicole was so bad as a judge on the sing off i may not tune into the x factor. already was questioning whether i would or not when i heard nicole was a co host. she's horrid. simon what are u NOT thinking!!

Not that I'll be watching (I don't watch unscripted TV), but, if I had to choose, I'd definitely watch Cheryl.

I agree with Rose. Somebody who is relevant in America.

It's going to be bad if The X-Factor doesn't do well in ratings. FOX stinks!