'American Idol': Didi Benami finds out 'What Becomes of the Broken Hearted'

it can't be her. she's loads better than some people still here like TIM URBAN, SEND HIM HOME ALREADY! SORRY CAPS

leave Tim in He needs more time Didi had a horrible attitude Tim kept on smiling and he has a great voice he just needs some more confidence I just think attitude can not be tolerated in any profession So let Tim sing 1 more time

Send Tim home!! Didi is way better. Just becoz she picked the wrong song doesnt mean she deserves to leave. Andrew had 4, 5 horrible weeks and he's still in. Didi deserves to be in 100 times compared to Tim.

People should not be eliminated based on one bad night. The different themes each week is not everyones style so why knock someone off because of that. It should be overall performances over a course of weeks.
That being said Andrew,Didi,and Tim bottom three.
Crystal for sure in finals, Lee is charging to the top, and I really like Siobhan dispite her so called first off week!

Tim needs to go--Didi is loads better than him anyday--how did he even get on the show to begin with?

Kara is, and always will be, a biased idiot who lets her *****-moans ( NOT misspelled) do her thinking.

She's been bad mouthing Didi for weeks. She lost her credibility a long time ago.

You insult everyone's intelligence by even mentioning her.

didi deserves to stay... even if the judges say that she did it bad.. that doesnt mean that all of the people heard it bad.. it wast bad.. it was just ok.. if your going to ask me.. i would prefer to hear didi one more time next week and see how she pulls herself back.. it's to bad that i cant vote for her because im not in america.. =(

I was beginning to think I was going deaf or tone deaf or something, but after re watching the performance I satnd by my first impression. She was very good last night if not great! I never heard this song before she sang it and it almost made me cry especially since she sang it her friend Rebecca who passed away. The judges officially suck! All except maybe Ellen. Be kind with the hate mail Didi haters.

I keep pulling for DiDi but she consistently disappoints. I can see she is trying and she has her heart in this competition 100% but her song choices are abysmal. I was crossing my fingers hoping she would do an acoustic performance of Roberta Flack's "The First Time Ever I Saw Your Face." In all fairness, she was 10 times better than Shioban (sp?) last night who was seriously atrocious. She should have went wild and performed "Lady Marmalade." What a terrible, terrible, embarrassing group of singers this year.

I'm Sorry but Didi has to go, when she sang "I'm no good, I'm no good, I'm no good," last week, oh, excuse me, thats "You're no good"- between that and last nights horrific song, I cringe now when she steps on the stage, her personality is blah too, I really don't know how she made it as far as she did. Personally as quirky as Lilly was, I would have enjoyed her more. Lee and Crystal are fighting over my #1 spot right now, and even Casey jammed last night. Tim would be my next person to go, but I still would rather watch him than Didi! Andrew, you were my first love, but I've grown tired of you trying to bring it back, and the screamer, how ever you spell her name, has became too weird for me, even though I loved when she sang "Freedom", Big Mike needs to R & B with some faster moves and beats, he has a terrific voice, but I'm in a coma by the time he finishes. Aaron has a great voice, he's just young but with the right people behind him- look out, I would love to see Crystal sing Smackwater Jack by Carol King. Crystal is very talented, when she did that CCR song "Candle in the Window" - if thats right, I just kept watching it over and over and over and over, Wow!