Follow Zap2it:

Emmys 2009: What should win best drama series?

madmen_cast_290.jpgLike the best comedy series category at the 61st annual Primetime Emmys, the best drama series category has seven nominees. Unlike the comedy competition, though, the field is a lot tighter.

"Mad Men" won last year, and because it's the Emmys, you should never underestimate the ability of voters to repeat themselves. But as with the comedy series category, the fact that there are seven nominees -- the result of the TV academy expanding the field to six nominees and a tie adding the seventh -- means that a show can win without anything even close to a majority of votes.

Here's how I'd rank the nominees; have your say in the poll below and in the comments (and don't forget to vote for best comedy and the comedy and drama lead acting polls too).

"Mad Men": AMC's drama won best drama after its first season and, in my mind, was even better in its second. Note-perfect performances and some of the most sharply drawn characters around make this show TV's best.

"Lost": Has any show in recent memory made a bigger course correction than "Lost"? I can't think of one. Season five kept the quality high, even while incorporating a mind-bending time-hopping story line.

"Breaking Bad": Bryan Cranston's amazing work in the lead role is what drives "Breaking Bad," but the way the show deepened the rest of its characters this year is really what made it work.

"Dexter": Fans weren't quite as sold on season three of Showtime's killer drama as they had been in the past, and it's probably too unapologetic about its twistedness to win the award. But it's still a hell of a lot of fun to watch.

"House": As a whole, the fifth season of FOX's medical drama was uneven. But few series had more talked-about episodes than Kutner's suicide or the season-ending spiral for Hugh Laurie's pill-addicted doctor.

"Damages": Brilliant acting and some big plot twists again fueled FX's take on the legal drama. But too often the second season felt like it threw in complications just for the sake of being complicated.

"Big Love": I like this show fine when I watch it, but it tends to fall through the cracks for me. I'm also not really sure whether voters would want to endorse a show about a polygamist family.



Follow Zap2it on Twitter for the latest TV, movie and celebrity news.

Related:

Zap2it's Emmy coverage
Emmys 2009: What should win best comedy series?
Emmys 2009: Pick the drama acting winners
Emmys 2009: Who do you like for comedy actor and actress?
2009 Emmy nominees
Follow Zap2it on Twitter and Zap2it on Facebook for the latest news and buzz
 
 
 
Zap2it Elite Sheet Must Reads from the Web's In-Crowd
 

DEXTER!!! I am totally hooked on that show! Great acting ... Michael C. Hall and Jennifer Carpenter are perfect in their respective roles. Never thought I would be such a fan of a serial killer! Discovered Michael C. Hall on 6ft Under - he was brilliant!

This is a tough call. I personally thought Mad Men took a step down from season 1. I also though Lost season 5, while mindblowing, wasn't its best. Breaking Bad took awhile to get going. House took 20 episodes to get going. Dexter was admittedly weaker after 2 very strong years. (I don't watch Big Love or Damages so I'm not going to comment on them)

Toss up between Lost and Mad Men for me, depends how the voters are feeling. I'd say the political answer would be give it to Mad Men, save one for Lost's finale year.

Considering I hated the second season of Mad Men, I'll say that's most likely the winner due to award show politics.

My vote on this pole went elsewhere....

LIFE LIFE LIFE LIFE LIFE LIFE AND OH YEAH....LIFE!!!!!!!!!

*poll

"BATTLESTAR GALACTICA" not on the list, not watching....

"THE SHIELD" not on the list, not watching....

"RESCUE ME" not on the list, not watching...

"TRUE BLOOD" not on the list, not watching...

Once again, too bad the good shows don't have enough money or powerful enough PR firms to get a seat at this sham.

Breaking Bad was the strongest drama this year. Season 3 of Dexter was noticeably weaker than the first two.

I would be happy seeing any of these dramas win, with the exception of "House" and "Big Love".

I enjoy most of the shows listed, but out of those seven, I think the best season definitely belonged to Damages.

Still not sure why The Shield wasn't nominated, and 24 as well.

This is a great piece. Very thought provoking. I like the sort of ending that leaves it opn to personal input. Makes it work for just about everyone I think. Nicely done! I’ll subscribe.

I am mesmerized by HOUSE.
And I also think that HUGH LAURIE deserves to win as well.

Zap2it Newsletter
Find it fast
Recent video

Gold Derby

 
 
What's On Tonight
Our Partners