From Inside the Box

'Heroes': Give us more Bryan Fuller, preferably on his own show

By Brill Bundy

   |  

March 29, 2009 6:20 PM

Bryanfuller Even though it hasn't officially renewed "Heroes" yet, NBC has been assuring the media that the superhero drama isn't going anywhere any time soon. At January's Press Tour they went as far as to say that its future is "very secure."

Which is a bit of a puzzle. Obviously expensive to produce, the show lost its way creatively in the second season. Viewers noticed and and its ratings quickly suffered and have never returned to their first season levels.

Last week, out of the blue, "Heroes" had a rare return to what made the show so great to begin with. "Cold Snap" was the reward for those who've stuck in for nearly two years waiting for the lost show to find its way back. Not to say that there was a giant payoff, or we're confident the showrunners suddenly know where they're going and what they're doing, but it was a top notch episode that gave us real conflict, characters we could care about again and a story we could be invested in.

What was different? It was written by producer Bryan Fuller ("Wonderfalls," "Dead Like Me"), who hasn't penned a script for the show since Season One's "Company Man." Fuller left "Heroes" after the first season in favor of producing his own show, "Pushing Daisies," for ABC. With "Daisies" canceled, Fuller is back in the "Heroes" fold.

Watching the episode, I idly Twittered: "Would you rather: Have Bryan Fuller keep writing 'Heroes' or get another new series all his own?"

The responses were swift and bountiful.

    "His own series, hands down. Maybe not quite as 'out there' as PD but at least a little bit 'out there' like Wonderfalls." -- @cabri

    "New series of his own, preferably on a cable net that will give him time and space." -- @coyotesqrl

    "New series, if the network will keep it on. New cable series maybe." -- @witnessaria

    "New series. He can do so much better than Heroes." -- @electrcspacegrl

    "Definitely his own show. His mind is too creative." -- @tvweek_vlada

    "Heroes is done - we need new shows to replace the void left by now-gone genuine programming like PD, ER, etc" -- @gdelrio

    "He should have another series of his own. His mind is too creative to be squandered on someone else's work." -- @BrionSwea

    "Speaking as someone who still adores Wonderfalls, I believe it's best he sticks with Heroes. For now. It was a good episode." -- @kwolfhard

    "I'd rather see Bryan Fuller get his own show rather than stick with HEROES." -- @GMMR

So, yea, kwolfhard aside, the consensus seems to be that "Heroes" time has come and gone.

Maybe we could have the best of both worlds and Fuller could helm a "Heroes" spin-off series. At this point, HRG might be the only one worth saving and starting fresh with.

What say you? Did "Cold Snap" renew your interest in "Heroes" in general or was it merely an anomaly? Or, have you already given up on the show and missed it altogether?

34 Comments

The sad thing about saying Bryan should stick to cable networks is -- that doesn't help him. Look at Dead Like Me. :/

I wish that some of our favorite showrunners could band together & have their own network. Bryan can write new funky series or continue his prematurely cancelled ones, Ron Moore could get Virtuality off the ground, Joss could have got Dollhouse off on the right foot (without network meddling that almost ruined it). I'm sure there are many more examples.

Networks are necessary evils, obviously, but I wish there was another option. They sacrifice creativity to the almighty ratings. (I still advocate a switch to the British or Japanese way of doing television. Smaller seasons, yes, but the freedom to take risks and knowledge that your work will still be seen.)


i thought the episode was average, not that much different in quality


As a fan of Heroesj, I loved the Ice Storm and our introduction to Rebel. I think we all like young people with powers. Like Baby Matt.


Since season one was largely derivative of other superhero stories, especially Watchmen, I am going to go ahead and say that this show is only really great when Bryan writes it. Some people have been asking NBC br*** about posibly mmimicking the Lost model and setting an end date for the show, but the difference is that even the episodes of Lost which were meandering around a bit during the second and third seasons were still damn good television. Heroes is too far gojne for me or anyone I know to care about it at all, and setting an end date would not change that becuase I really do think the writers mostly make it up on the fly and have no idea what they are doing. They need to give Heroes a mercy killing and have Fuller write the finale.


I quit watching after a few episodes this season, after sticking through season 2. I just couldn't take it anymore.

While I adore Bryan Fuller, I just can't bring myself to jump back in. NBC has a history of ruining many good things, and I'm too afraid of getting burned again.

(I'm still livid with ABC over the cancellation of PUSHING DAISIES, though. I watch a lot of cable now.)


i gave up on this show long ago! i think it's already too corrupted to get back the large viewership. i think he'd be a lot better off just starting fresh with a new show.


too little too late.


I still adore Heroes, but I admit I love the show even more whenever Bryan Fuller writes an episode. You can really tell a difference.


Ah ha. So that's why HEROES has been picking up again. So can someone explain to me why PD left us fans hanging? (Damn you, Mouse!)


heroes is still good people give it a chance, too many haters.


Post a comment

 optional
 optional
 
Find it fast

Zap2it on Facebook
twitter Zap2it Twitter Talk
Recent posts