From Inside the Box

'Grey's Anatomy': It's fine. I'm fine.

By Rick Porter

   |  

October 19, 2006 11:40 PM

Katherineheigl2_greysanatomy_s3_240Busy, busy night in Seattle Grace, and a really strong one too. My only real nitpick: Even if Izzie isn't going to deposit that $8.7 million check just yet, could she at least put it someplace safer than on the door of the fridge?

Thursday's episode was a good showcase for Katherine Heigl, even if half her lines were "It's fine. I'm fine." Izzie wasn't really fooling anyone, but her little bits of self-sabotage with the check and the time she spent at her locker showed just how much she was trying to fool herself into believing what she was saying.

Chandra Wilson, week to week the most consistently strong performer on the show, also had a big, meaty story, beginning with Bailey throwing herself under the bus at Denny's M&M (morbidity and mortality) conference. Subsequently she backed away from a breast-cancer patient (Six Feet Under's Justina Machado), against her better instincts, so as not to get emotionally invested in the case as she had -- and as she let her interns do -- with Denny. You knew how this was going to end, of course, but Wilson sold it really well.

Even McDreamy getting all McHuffy when Addison told him about her affair with Mark made sense this time, given how long she'd kept that from him for a good year and that he'd just signed away a bunch of property in the divorce. It also allowed Mark to show some of his first flashes of humanity in his reaction to Addison's continued keeping of that secret: "I'm just the chump who seduced his wife for the hell of it. Real fair."

Then there was the funny medical case (Arye Gross!), which started out as an exercise in detente between Meredith and Addison and then became the serious medical emergency that brought togehter Izzie's latent desire to get back into surgery, Burke's struggles getting his game back and Addison's lingering guilt. Grey's has done this sort of theme-expressing case a number of times in its history, and this was one of the show's better efforts in that regard.

And all that activity means we got to push Meredith and Derek to the background this week, which is just fine with me. Nice to see them riding the elevator again (first time this season, right?), but there's more interesting ground to cover elsewhere on the show at the moment.


7 Comments

Interesting to note that Addison was basically saying to Derek that the only reason she even bothered to fight for her marriage was because Mark cheated on her and it hurt/snapped her to her senses to she went back to the guy she cheated on to make nice.


Unlike some of the melodrama you get on some shows that's just too over the top, this one consistently keeps with within a reasonable boundaries (for the most part).

And the ability to make the characters very well rounded and sympathetic is amazing. In how many other shows would Addison come out as such a sympathetic character?? In every other show she would have been the evil-ex just around to get in the way of the heroes.

...Course maybe it helps that I think Kate Walsh is a great actor and may be the hottest of the women on the show...


Is it just me, but I prefer Addison to Meredith. I'd rather she get back with McDreamy and Meredith with Finn or somebody else.


McBurke and Izzy have gobs of chemistry. I think they should have an affair or atleast a one night stand. None of their scenes are meant to be but they are hot! This is Grey's, they could do it and make it work.


I agree with both Robert and BJ. First with Robert, because when Addision showed up at the end of season 1 i wanted to hate her. i mean i really tried... but i ended up loving her and caring more about her than i did for meredith or derek. I mean she made a mistake, but somehow it just comes off incredably human and i have to forgive her.

Secondly with BJ because burke and izzy do have a lot of chemistry, but i put alot of that to Isiah Washington, he seems to have great chemistry with alot of the other actors. In the scenes with george, i honestly believed they could be good friends.


I agree with Ange, I prefer Addison to both Meredith and Derek. Meredith's character just seem too weak and wishy-washy. I would also prefer to see Addison with Derek.


No, no, no. I do not agree that Addison & McDreamy should get back together. Too much bad carma....

Meredith & McDreamy for sure.

Very good show! My #2 pick of the season!

Keep up the good work.


Post a comment

 optional
 optional
 
Find it fast

Zap2it on Facebook
twitter Zap2it Twitter Talk
Recent posts