Photos
Video
'American Idol' Post-Performance Chat Live!
Tune in at this post in about 30 minutes for a chat with "American Idol" experts about last night's country performances. Who did a two-step all around the floor to success? Whose woman left them and whose dog died on the road to tanking on Country Night? Check it out here at 3 pm eastern/2 pm central.
5 Comments
Zap2it Twitter Talk 
I WOULD LIKE TO KNOW FROM SOMEONE ON THE EAST COAST WHO WAS PUT OFF ON AMERICAN IDOL 18 MAR 2009. THANKS
What was the deal with Carrie Underwood's hair? Please tell me that was a wig.
It is very clear to me and I am now convinced that Simon calls the shots on American Idol and not the American vote. Megan Joy is unique, talented, and gorgeous and Simon knows this. Get over it Simon and be a man! You, as well as America, know that Megan should not have been kicked off just because she hurt your feelings! Be a man Simon and GROW UP!! America will be seeing plenty of Megan Joy.
Get rid of Kara. Her critiques make no sense. I'm sure she's a nice person but so unnecessary. Makes the show too long.
Is it just me, or is there some subtle discrimination here... I mean Scott was a nice singer, and I did like him at the piano but he was not great...and other contestants who are so much better got completely panned some weeks while the judges were just sooooo nice to him. Like Tuesday night, those high notes he sang, and the guitar, that was pretty bad, and the only one really with the balls to be truthful and tell him it was bad was Simon, thank god.
There was a bit of walking on eggshells with him I think and if I were him I'd be offended.
And don't think I'm discriminating against him, I'm blind too so I know what it looks like when pity is covered up by praise and admiration and "wow" you are such an inspiration.....hell, he doesn't sing with his eyes, he sings with his voice...and his heart.
Anyone have the balls to reply.............