Recap: 'American Idol' Reaches its Top 12
Thank heavens for American Idol and the interruption it offers from wall-to-wall coverage of Brett Favre's retirement. In my book, he was maybe the ninth or 10th best quarterback in NFL history and only the seventh or eighth best There's Something About Mary star. Does that deserve three days of non-stop ESPN coverage? Really? I mean, maybe if he'd been making his living as a stripper at gay clubs in Phoenix... So anyway, who will be eliminated on Thursday (March 6) night in the final Idol cuts before the Top 12?
8:00 p.m. Unveiling the kind of uncomfortable looking stools I'd expect at a soda fountain (is he on the new stage?), Ryan Seacrest warns me that this is American Idol and we're presenting the Top 12 tonight. That means four contestants are going home tonight -- Luke Menard, Kady Malloy and two other people.
8:01 p.m. Geez. Blake Lewis finished second last season. I'd forgotten about the Human Beatbox Version 6.1. It's a little interesting that Idol is letting Blake pimp himself before they give time to Jordin Sparks. They both need the sales boost. Blake is actually pretty decent, though the song is a snooze.
8:05 p.m. "It's a big night every night to lose four people," Blake tells Ryan in response to the host's contention that this elimination is particularly important. Then he tells the contestants to listen to the judges' positive criticisms. Thanks, Blake!
8:09 p.m. Ah. There are the uncomfortable seats. They're right next to where the Top 16 are sitting, but there are only 12 of chairs, to be filled by the fruits of 36 million Idol votes. In one smooth piece of pimping, Ryan manages to plug Paula's new single, the show's new iTunes partnership and the exposure the song got on Ryan's radio show.
8:11 p.m. The guys will start on the hot seat, but only after a prolonged recap of Tuesday night's '80s-inflected performance, somehow leaving out Randy's inability to distinguish between INXS and Simple Minds. Fortunately, Presumptive American Idol Winner David Archuleta's earnest tribute to the homeless is included.
8:14 p.m. Ryan wishes everybody luck and then starts singling out performances. David Cook, regrowing his soul patch and coming off a bang-up performance of "Hello," is in the Top 12. Finally he can get plugs! Presumptive American Idol Winner David Archuleta is up next. Well, he can't win if he doesn't make the Top 12 and he's through as well. Jason "The Stoned Muppet" Castro earned high praise this week. He was less impressive when I re-listened to him, but he's also in the Top 12. Hey Ryan, can you make this process any more excruciating? Ah yes. By selling product.
8:17 p.m. A trip to ESPN reveals that Brett Favre is still retired.
8:21 p.m. Ah. Now, even without eliminating anybody, we're on to Wednesday's performances by the Women. Ramiele Malubay was really bad. And sorry, even though nearly everybody seems to love her, I can't get on the Brooke White bandwagon.
8:25 p.m. I obviously don't matter. I know this. Brooke is the first gal sent over to the Top 12. Simon, Paula and Randy agree that Syesha Mercado should go through to the Top 12 and America agrees. Kady Malloy is up next. She knows she's going home and she's nodding before Ryan gets to the results. Even her loved ones in the crowd don't seem surprised.
Yeah, but we knew Kady was doomed. Who else went home?
Well, you're gonna have to check out the full recap over at our It Happened Last Night blog.
Are You 'Idol' Material?
Click here to upload your audition video for Zap2it readers to view!Zap2it TV Talk
Latest Posts
- New 'American Idol' Judge Promises Honesty, Awaits Unique Singers
- 'American Idol' Exit Interview: David Cook
- 'American Idol' Exit Interview: David Archuleta
- 'American Idol' Finale Ratings Up
- Recap: A New 'American Idol' Crowned
- Recap: 'American Idol' Finale -- The Davids Enter the Ring
- 'American Idol' Power: Neil Diamond crushes Clay Aiken on the charts
- FOX Exec: Happy with 'American Idol' creatively, not its performance
- 'American Idol' Exit Interview: Syesha Mercado
- Recap: 'American Idol' Sets its Top Two
- Recap: Thrice As Nice for 'American Idol' Top Three
- 'American Idol' vs. David Archuleta's Dad
- 'American Idol' Exit Interview: Jason Castro
- Recap: Dread-ful elimination on 'American Idol'
- Recap: 'American Idol' can't stop the rock
- 'American Idol' Exit Interview: Brooke White
- Recap: Brooke runs dry on 'American Idol'
- Recap: 'American Idol' seeks a Diamond in the rough
- Is 'American Idol' ready to make changes?
- 'American Idol' Exit Interview: Carly Smithson
- Recap: 'American Idol' plucks an Irish Rose
- Meet Kevin Covais, Movie Star
- Andrew Lloyd Webber Grills 'American Idol' Top Six
- 'American Idol' Exit Interview: Kristy Lee Cook
- Recap: Too Many Cooks in the 'American Idol' Kitchen
Other American Idol Sites
Weekly 'American Idol' Photo Galleries
- 'American Idol 7' - Top 12 Party
- 'American Idol 7' Performances: Top 8 Women
- 'American Idol 7' Performances: Top 8 Men
- 'American Idol 7' Performances: Top 10 Women
- 'American Idol 7' Performances: Top 10 Men
- 'American Idol 7' Performances: Top 12 Women
- 'American Idol 7' Performances: Top 12 Men
- 'American Idol' Season 7 Top 24 Party
- 'American Idol' Season 7 Top 24
- 'American Idol' Season 7 Photos
- 'American Idol' Season 7 Auditions
Shows We Recap
- 30 Rock
- 90210
- The Amazing Race
- American Gladiators
- American Idol
- America's Best Dance Crew
- America's Got Talent
- America's Next Top Model
- The Celebrity Apprentice
- Army Wives
- Baby Borrowers
- The Bachelor: London Calling
- The Bachelorette
- Battlestar Galactica
- The Big Bang Theory
- Big Brother
- The Biggest Loser
- The Biggest Loser: Families
- Big Love
- Bones
- Boston Legal
- Brothers & Sisters
- Burn Notice
- Californication
- Chuck
- The Closer
- CSI
- Curb Your Enthusiasm
- Damages
- Dancing with the Stars
- Desperate Housewives
- Dexter
- Dirty Sexy Money
- Eli Stone
- Entourage
- Fringe
- Ghost Whisperer
- Gossip Girl
- Greatest American Dog
- Greek
- Grey's Anatomy
- Hell's Kitchen
- The Hills
- Heroes
- High School Musical: Get in the Picture
- House
- How I Met Your Mother
- In Plain Sight
- Kitchen Nightmares
- Knight Rider
- Kyle XY
- The L Word
- Last Comic Standing
- Lipstick Jungle
- Lost
- Mad Men
- Make Me A Supermodel
- Meerkat Manor: The Next Generation
- The Mentalist
- The Middleman
- The Mole
- My Boys
- My Name Is Earl
- Nashville Star
- NCIS
- The Office
- One Tree Hill
- Prison Break
- Private Practice
- Privileged
- Project Runway
- Pushing Daisies
- Reaper
- Rescue Me
- Saving Grace
- Scrubs
- The Secret Life of the American Teenager
- Shear Genius
- The Shield
- Smallville
- So You Think You Can Dance
- Step It Up & Dance
- Supernatural
- Survivor: Gabon
- Swingtown
- Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles
- Top Chef
- Top Design
- Ugly Betty
- Weeds
Nielsen Top Shows
- Dancing with the Stars
- Grey's Anatomy
- Desperate Housewives
- NCIS
- CSI: Miami
- Criminal Minds
- The Mentalist
- Two and a Half Men
- CSI: NY
